Skip to content

H.M.S. Bounty, Unlikely Timeship | Can We Save The Whales?

Jeremy Rowe PhotoJeremy Rowe

November 3, 2026

Are Whales viable in Commander? Jeremy gets into the bathysphere to explore what a H.M.S. Bounty, Unlikely Timeship might actually entail.

Background image for H.M.S. Bounty, Unlikely Timeship | Can We Save The Whales?

H.M.S. Bounty, Unlikely Timeship | Art by Jetfreak-7

Sometimes, all it takes for a commander to make me want to build around it is for it to make me laugh, and I hope this breakdown makes you laugh as hard as the card made me laugh.

I’m not going to sugarcoat it: I’m not a Star Trek fan. And I know folks have their hangups about Universes Beyond, myself included.

But one of the neat things that comes with Universes Beyond is that there are a lot of cute, experimental designs. Some of my favorite commanders come from IPs I don’t particularly care for, but I appreciate the design and like how the card functions as a game piece.

Is Whale typal even possible? And would anyone losing to it be able to live it down?

As the resident EDHREC typal master, I'm here to do a bit of analysis.

What Does H.M.S. Bounty, Unlikely Timeship Do?

With the advent of Edge of Eternities, legendary Vehicles and Spacecraft were granted the right to serve as commanders. H.M.S. Bounty, Unlikely Timeship is a legendary Spacecraft. Ergo, it can be a commander.

But what kind of commander is H.M.S. Bounty, Unlikely Timeship?

When our commander enters, we can tutor (search for) and put in hand a Whale card. When stationed, the Bounty becomes a 3/4 flyer that draws a card when it connects with an opponent.

But what’s so exciting about it?

Well, specifically mentioning Whales is already cool enough, but it has another ability that references Whales. As part of the combat damage trigger, it checks to see if the controller also controls a Whale. If so, and if the player hasn’t taken an extra turn this game, they take an extra turn.

But is any of this worth it?

Five mana to tutor for a Whale, make a time-delayed flying Ophidian, and conditionally take an extra turn seems…underwhelming in today’s world of immediate gratification. But as a Whale commander? That’s where we could have some fun.

Whales have been in Magic since Exodus's Killer Whale, though Narwhal, from Homelands, was errata'd to Whale later on. And, like Narwhals living in the ocean, the idea of making a Whale typal deck seems like a meme.

Still, meme decks can be a lot of fun, and unique typal decks are some of my favorites.

But, like the typal analysis of Sphinx's Approach, an evaluation of H.M.S. Bounty, Unlikely Timeship starts with the payoff: for the card to be good, the cards it tutors up need to be worth the mana investment.

So what Whales are worth searching for?

Whale Tutor Targets

For a more controlling build, Colossal Whale is a solid source of repeatable removal. It’s a 5/5 with islandwalk that can exile a creature the defending player controls each time it attacks. It does give the creatures back when it leaves the battlefield, but, if there’s another blue player, it can pick their board apart. Even if there isn’t, Colossal Whale can still remove blockers.

Great Whale is more of a combo card, which is to be expected from Urza’s Saga. It has one of the more broken mechanics to come out of the set: when it enters, we untap up to seven lands. This can get really silly if we play with cards like High Tide and bounce or blink spells. In fact, bounce spells would let us re-use our commander’s ETB effect and would emulate whales’ breaching.

Star Whale is an excellent budget finisher for a ramp or Polymorph deck, as an 8/8 vigilance flyer that gives other creatures ward 2. It’s not great when cast for 8 mana, but it can be tutored for with the commander and then quickly suspended for 6 turns for the low, low cost of two mana.

Dreamtide Whale might just be the best tutor target for the Bounty, and might just be the best card in the deck as a whole. In addition to being a large body for a small mana investment, it lets us proliferate when the second spell in anyone’s turn is cast. This gets around its vanishing downside, but also helps us add charge counters to get our commander stationed. It has exactly seven power, so it stations our commander with one activation plus a single proliferation!

What Directions Do Whales Take?

When trying to build around an undersupported creature type, it helps to line up the members of the type and look into what card types and effects they care about, as well as what their curve looks like and what their average stats and abilities are like.

To start with, there are only twenty Whales in Magic, and two of them are multicolored, so they can’t fit in our mono-blue Whale deck. There are another twenty changeling spells in mono-blue, so we actually have 38 Whales, a solid number, and possibly enough to make a functioning deck.

But what kind of deck is it?

There are six Whales that we can play or use in the first three turns, as well as 14 changelings that can be cast in the first few turns. The changelings help to fill in the early slots and give the deck a way to present a board while setting up.

The meme deck might just have a chance.

What Do Whales Require?

While most Whales are just large creatures, including a surprising number of medium-to-large flyers, there are a few that inform the support the deck will need.

Cetacean Ops and Ethereal Forager both work well with noncreature spells. Cetacean Ops grows when we cast any kind of noncreature spell, while Ethereal Forager cares about instants and sorceries specifically. It has delve to reduce its cost, and then can put instants and sorceries exiled to pay for its delve cost to our hand when it attacks, giving us extra spells, if we’ve built our deck to take advantage.

Steelfin Whale, meanwhile, has affinity for artifacts to reduce its cost. It also untaps whenever an artifact enters under our control. While it’s the only Whale that explicitly cares about artifacts, our commander IS an artifact. That, and Cetacean Ops only caring about noncreatures and our mana-hungry deck wanting mana rocks, means that building around artifacts could be a solid plan.

Makes sense, considering the type got support in sci-fi settings, like Kaladesh, Dr. Who, Edge of Eternities, and Star Trek.

What Would a Whale Deck Actually Look Like?

In order to see if this meme deck is viable, as well as to place the deck in a Bracket, it helps to look into what the general plan is in each phase of the game. This is a generally good way to evaluate your deck and a strategy for deck design and making those dreaded last few cuts.

Turns 1-3

As mentioned, we have 20 Whales and/or changelings that can be cast in the first few turns. We want more of those, so we can enable our mid-to-late-game plays and bridge the mana gap in our deck.

As a result, we want to play cards like Sol Ring (big surprise) and Mind Stone (notably not The Mind Stone). Deckbuilding guides will often mention “eating your vegetables” as “running a certain amount of an effect,” but, to make a deck work well, we also need to make sure we’re cognizant of how those effects mesh with what the deck is doing and when the deck needs the effect.

For example, Mind Stone ramps when we need it, in the early game, while Hedron Archive, which makes more mana and can draw more cards, is more of a mid-game card.

Instead, we’d rather run High Tide or Energy Tap, which make that burst of mana later but also help us earlier on.

Turns 4-7

This is where we want to be casting our higher-cost Whales. In an ideal game, we want to be slamming our fifteen 4-7 cost Whales around this time, as well as our commander.

This is why we need mana ramp; we need to not only be hitting our land drops but be ahead on mana, just like a struggling offense in American football needs to gain yards on first and second down to take pressure off of third (also known as “staying ahead of the chains/sticks”).

Slamming these big Whales on the board is important because, as is often the case with typal decks, our card quality depreciates as the game goes on. Star Whale’s 8/8 flying vigilant body is a solid beater, but can easily get outclassed by, say, a Blightsteel Colossus or a Metalwork Colossus. It’s also a 5-turn clock against one player, so we need to be starting that clock ASAP.

Because we have so many Whales we want to be adding to the board, as well as our commander, we don’t need to play a lot of non-Whale creatures during this phase of the game.

Turns 8+

Later in the game, we want to be closing things out or protecting our board while we do so. Our Whales are plenty big enough to bash faces, but starting over on an empty board is not something we want to be doing.

Our commander gives us a powerful effect to use in the late game to finish things out, but we need to make the most out of the extra turn it provides.

To that end, cards like Negate to counter board wipes or March of Swirling Mist to phase our creatures out in response to removal help us keep the mid-game momentum going. It’s important to note that this is the intended role of the cards in the deck because Negate will almost certainly have early targets but we don’t want to burn it and then get wiped and caught with our metaphorical pants down.

Bracket

Because we are prioritizing the Whale theme over power, using substandard win conditions, showing off all the Whales we can, and taking at least 9 turns before being able to close a game out, this deck can be considered a Bracket 1, but that might not be the best place for it.

Since we do have an incremental, telegraphed, and disruptible game plan, and we are fairly mechanically focused, Bracket 2 could also work. It’s easier to find Bracket 2 games, so I think Bracket 2 is probably a better place for a Whale deck, even if it is a bit underpowered. If it’s having trouble keeping up, slotting in some bounce spells could help.

Conclusion

H.M.S. Bounty, Unlikely Timeship is an intriguing commander, and I am definitely a fan. I could even see myself trying to build it for myself, but with bounce spells as the late-game cards, like Evacuation.

This is a new outline, which I like for evaluating under-supported creature types. Let me know what you think of it!

And how would YOU build Whales?

Jeremy Rowe

Jeremy Rowe

Teacher, judge, DM, & Twitch Affiliate. Lover of all things Unsummon. Streams EDH, Oathbreaker, D & D, & Pokemon. Even made it to a Pro Tour!

Want more Commander content, right in your inbox?

To stay on top of all our news, features, and deck techs, sign up for our EDHRECap e-mail newsletter.

EDHREC Code of Conduct

Your opinions are welcome. We love hearing what you think about Magic! We ask that you are always respectful when commenting. Please keep in mind how your comments could be interpreted by others. Personal attacks on our writers or other commenters will not be tolerated. Your comments may be removed if your language could be interpreted as aggressive or disrespectful. You may also be banned from writing further comments.