Making Clues With Nyla, Shirshu Sleuth in Commander

by
Ezra Sassaman
Ezra Sassaman
Making Clues With Nyla, Shirshu Sleuth in Commander

Nyla, Shirshu SleuthNyla, Shirshu Sleuth | Art by Douzen

Welcome to another deck tech showcasing a new commander. For this week, let's take a look at Nyla, Shirshu SleuthNyla, Shirshu Sleuth, the Shirshu companion of expert bounty hunter June (depicted in the Avatar set as June, Bounty HunterJune, Bounty Hunter).

Nyla has a really powerful sense of smell and uses this advantage to help June track her targets. In Magic, this means being able to create a lot of Clues – but we're getting ahead of ourselves, that's for the next section!

Just like in previous articles, we're here to...

  • Highlight interesting game plan(s) for a new commander.
  • Build a budget-friendly (~$40) "Core" power level deck following these plans.
  • Work through important card categories and discuss notable inclusions.
  • Include a deck list and a deck checklist.
  • Go through mid-budget upgrades (<$20 per card) as options to invest more into this strategy.

What Does Nyla, Shirshu SleuthNyla, Shirshu Sleuth Do?

Nyla, Shirshu Sleuth

Nyla's most exciting ability is creating a large number of ClueClue tokens if we exile a high mana value creature card from our graveyard. There are many ways to take advantage of this powerful ability, including cards that like creating and sacrificing artifacts or tokens – and cards that like having a lot of artifacts in play.

The basic game plan is this:

  1. Get a high mana value creature into our graveyard.
  2. Cast Nyla and create a bunch of Clues.
  3. Use cards that synergize with these Clues to build an advantage.
  4. Disrupt our opponents' plans with all sorts of spells.

So how are we going to pull this off? Let's go through these categories in order.

Getting a High Mana Value Creature Into the Graveyard

One of the easiest ways to get a high mana value creature into our graveyard is by discarding it to its own cycling ability. This way, we only have to pay a few mana to get a six-six-, seven-seven-, or even eight-eight-mana creature into the yard.

These creatures also naturally help us draw more cards/find more lands, which is already what we want to be doing in the early game. Win-win!

There are also a few creatures we can get into play for much less mana than their actual mana value, either with improviseimprovise, morphmorph, or prototypeprototype. Once these creatures die, they'll be perfect targets for our commander.

Artifact/Clue Synergies

Artifacts/Clues Entering or Dying

Marionette Apprentice
Nadier's Nightblade
Persuasive Interrogators

Especially in recent sets, has emerged as a color that cares about artifacts and tokens entering, dying, and being sacrificed.

Creatures like Arcbound CondorArcbound Condor, Pactdoll TerrorPactdoll Terror, Al Bhed SalvagersAl Bhed Salvagers, Susurian VoidbornSusurian Voidborn, and Mirkwood BatsMirkwood Bats are great examples of ways this strategy has been boosted in just the last few years.

And don't forget older classics like Disciple of the VaultDisciple of the Vault and Marionette MasterMarionette Master!

Artifacts/Clues Staying on the Battlefield

Monumental Corruption
Battle at the Bridge
Inspiring Statuary

But it's not just about artifacts entering and dying in various ways – a board full of ClueClue tokens can also be powerful just by being on the battlefield.

Cards like Armix, Filigree ThrasherArmix, Filigree Thrasher and Demonic JunkerDemonic Junker provide useful disruption. All-star Equipment like Adaptive OmnitoolAdaptive Omnitool, Cranial PlatingCranial Plating, and NettlecystNettlecyst can threaten to end the game quickly, especially stacked on top of each other or on other cards with similar abilities like Monoist Circuit-FeederMonoist Circuit-Feeder and Brotherhood VertibirdBrotherhood Vertibird.

Finally, cards like Academy ManufactorAcademy Manufactor and Foggy Swamp VisionsFoggy Swamp Visions can turn ClueClue production into a sudden burst of advantage.

Sacrificing Clues at Will

Umbral Collar Zealot
Keskit, the Flesh Sculptor
Tamiyo's Journal

ClueClue tokens do have the built-in ability to sacrifice themselves for , but some cards reward us for sacrificing them for free (most notably Persuasive InterrogatorsPersuasive Interrogators, the card with the initial highest synergy score with Nyla).

ClueClue sacrifice engines can allow us to produce lots of manaproduce lots of mana, filter throughfilter through or drawdraw cards, create a formidable threatcreate a formidable threat, or reanimate a ton of creatures at oncereanimate a ton of creatures at once.

Black Disruption

Now we understand how to get our proactive, ClueClue-centric plans up and running. But which cards in our color identity can we use to stop our opponents from executing their game plans?

Bone ShardsBone Shards and Bitter TriumphBitter Triumph are targeted removal spells that also allow us to discard high mana creatures for our commander to harvest for Clues.

Consuming CorruptionConsuming Corruption and Tendrils of CorruptionTendrils of Corruption can take down a large opposing threat while undoing some of Nyla's life loss.

The new on-theme printing Raven EagleRaven Eagle and the classic lands Bojuka BogBojuka Bog and Scavenger GroundsScavenger Grounds disrupt opposing graveyard-based strategies.

Finally, Archenemy's CharmArchenemy's Charm is a great reason to be in mono-black, as it serves as a versatile removal, recursion, or lifegain spell as the game state requires.

Nyla, Shirshu Sleuth Commander Deck List


Nyla, Shirshu Sleuth

View on Archidekt

Commander (1)

Creatures (33)

Artifacts (12)

Enchantments (3)

Instants (7)

Sorceries (6)

Lands (38)

Nyla, Shirshu Sleuth

Deck Checklist

  • 47 mana sources (38 lands, 4 landcycling creatures, 2 mana rocks, 3 misc.)
  • 16 cards that care about Clues entering/leaving/dying/being sacrificed
  • 15 cards that care about having a lot of Clues on the battlefield
  • 15 creatures with mana value six or greater
  • 12 targeted disruption
  • 11 card draw/selection/search/recursion
  • 5 mass disruption

Mid-Budget Upgrades

Fomori Vault
Arcbound Ravager
Ripples of Undeath

We can get nostalgic with the artifact-centric original Mirrodin block and try out some combination of Arcbound RavagerArcbound Ravager, Mycosynth GolemMycosynth Golem, Grinding StationGrinding Station, Krark-Clan IronworksKrark-Clan Ironworks, and Blinkmoth UrnBlinkmoth Urn. We can even pair them with sweet new tech in Tezzeret, Cruel CaptainTezzeret, Cruel Captain. (Yes, Mycosynth Golem is a little above the usual budget for upgrades, but it is so on-theme as a high mana value creature that also cares about having a lot of artifacts on the battlefield that we can make an exception).

We can upgrade the land suite with

We can fill our graveyard for Nyla with Ripples of UndeathRipples of Undeath or blink our commander each turn with Conjurer's ClosetConjurer's Closet.

Finally, we can include Withering TormentWithering Torment to deal with pesky enchantments like Rest in PeaceRest in Peace and sleeve up the classic DamnationDamnation if we're expecting creature-heavy opponents (the normal classic sweeper Toxic DelugeToxic Deluge doesn't pair well with our self-inflicted life loss).

Conclusion

I hope you enjoyed reading about this low-budget Core deck inspired by a new commander. Can you see any other fun ways to take advantage of this Clue-happy mono-black commander? Or do you think Nyla is a better fit in an existing Clue-based strategy with access to more colors instead?

Let the EDHREC community know in the comments below!

Ezra Sassaman

Ezra Sassaman


Based in Maine, Ezra started playing Magic around when Ravnica: City of Guilds came out and hasn't looked back since! Besides Commander, he enjoys any format where you can look across the whole history of the game, so Cube drafting has a special place in his heart!

Want more Commander content, right in your inbox?
To stay on top of all our news, features, and deck techs, sign up for our EDHRECap e-mail newsletter.

EDHREC Code of Conduct

Your opinions are welcome. We love hearing what you think about Magic! We ask that you are always respectful when commenting. Please keep in mind how your comments could be interpreted by others. Personal attacks on our writers or other commenters will not be tolerated. Your comments may be removed if your language could be interpreted as aggressive or disrespectful. You may also be banned from writing further comments.