Skip to content

Bracket For Your Buck - Multiple Brackets, Low Budget

Brian Cain PhotoBrian Cain

March 4, 2025

Low budget bracket brews take the spotlight in this week's Brew for Your Buck!

Background image for Bracket For Your Buck - Multiple Brackets, Low Budget
Vito, Thorn of the Dusk Rose | Art by Lie Setiawan

Bracketology

Hello fellow brewer and welcome back to Brew For Your Buck, where we swap out the top 10 most expensive cards in a deck with 10 budget cards that add a unique twist.

If you're not up on your giant, sweeping, format news, Wizards of the Coast released the beta format for the new bracket system for clarifying power levels and simplifying Rule Zero conversations.

Check out this article for more details. I love the bracket system for a number of reasons, one of the big ones being it gives Brew For Your Buck yet another angle to approach budget deckbuilding, which is exactly what we're going to do today.

If you haven't seen one of my "Hot Swap" articles before, this will be similar, in that we are going to build multiple decks in one go. But, instead of designing the budget package around multiple viable commanders, we're going to have multiple packages that you can swap in to play at different power levels.

If that sounds complicated, that's because it is, so we're going to go with a mono-colored commander to keep the rest of the complexity down. So we'll go with the mono-best color:

Vito is a perfect commander for our bracket-swapping deck, since he can be a part of a two card infinite combo with Exquisite Blood and Bloodthirsty Conqueror, both in the average list already.

Speaking of, that list clocks in at $321.20. Here's the top 10 pricey cards:

            1. Vampiric Tutor ($42.53)
            2. Demonic Tutor ($36.10)
            3. Bloodthirsty Conqueror ($31.89)
            4. Bloodletter of Aclazotz ($31.75)
            5. Exquisite Blood ($17.09)
            6. Aetherflux Reservoir ($13.78)
            7. Alhammarret's Archive ($13.50)
            8. Bloodchief Ascension ($12.20)
            9. Black Market Connections ($8.97)
            10. Sorin Markov ($4.22)

Total Value of Cuts: $212.03

Cabal Coffers and Cabal Stronghold are the two expensive lands to replace, and they'll lead to an additional $27.13 in savings, for a total of $239.16.

Looking at those 12 cards, we have two game-changers and both of the infinite combo cards I mentioned before. So the average list looks like it will fall well into bracket four.

This is perfect! Not only will removing these cards reduce the price of the deck, but makes for a bracket package all on its own. We're also going to remove Bolas's Citadel for now.

Normally it would remain in the list, but since it's a "game changer" it needs to come out, at least for Bracket 2. So now we'll look at two different budget packages, one for each of Bracket 2 and Bracket 3.

Additions

Bracket 2

Bracket 2's described identity is that it should be on the same power level of a precon, so I decided to go with a Vampire-typal focus, since we've had a few of those precons in the past.

There are 19 Vampires in the deck already; low for a typical kindred deck but still serviceable, especially as we add some more. Of course, Vito's ability wants us to focus on a lifegain theme too, so we'll have plenty to add for our Bracket 2 package.

Nirkana Revenant ($6.34) pushes the budget limit, but it's just too powerful not to include in a mono-black deck. In a similar vein, (hehe, Vampire pun) Crossway Troublemakers ($0.15) allows all of your attacks to deal "double damage" with Vito on the battlefield, and force trades if your opponents dare to block.

Captivating Vampire ($0.94) is a lord while enabling the theft of opposing commanders, which is one of the best ways to deal with them. We also add Kalastria Highborn ($0.87), some removal insurance that can trigger your lifegain payoffs, including Vito.

Bloodline Keeper's ($3.67) price dropped with it's reprint in Innistrad Remastered, so now's a good time to pick up one of those for any Vampire deck.

To round out our new Vampires, I've thrown in Sanguine Syphoner, Vampire Gourmand, and Drana, Liberator of Malakir, which lean slightly more aggressive to keep up the (blood) pressure on opponents.

Finally, two Vampire support cards: Olivia's Wrath is not only what happens when I annoy my wife, but is a great card for any Vampire deck.

Meanwhile, Mask of Griselbrand is a fantastic source of card velocity, in addition to granting lifelink for synergy and flying to get through during combat.

All in all, a great Vampire-themed package to swap in for lower powered tables. The total cost of this package is $13.40, with nearly half of that being Nirkana Revenant. You can always swap that out for a cheaper Vampire if you're looking to save even more.

Bracket 3

Bracket 3 is more tuned by definition, and is allowed to have up to three game changers plus "late game" two card infinite combos. We've got one game changer already, Bolas's Citadel, which by default becomes a part of this package.

We'll also add Aetherflux Reservoir back into the deck. These two don't go truly infinite without Sensei's Divining Top, but can get pretty darn close. Reservoir also works great with Vito on the field.

Our Bracket 3 package will include some cards to help support using Bolas's Citadel, while also giving us some more powerful support for Vito and friends.

Most of the tutors were removed and won't be coming back in unless we swap to Bracket 4, but fortunately they aren't the only tutors out there. That's right, it's time once again for BFYB star, Mausoleum Secrets ($0.69).

Maus-rets is right at home in a creature heavy, mono-black deck like this one, finding anything we need at instant speed at the low cost of a few creatures in the yard.

We can also add Grim Servant ($0.13) which gets pretty close to its namesake Grim Tutor with all the black pips we'll have on the battlefield. We'll throw in Lively Dirge ($0.44) as a combination recursion/tutor effect we can use to find key Vampires like Twilight Prophet or Blood Artist.

Speaking of Blood Artist, I'm also going to throw in Forsaken Miner ($0.32) and Viscera Seer ($0.50). Vito's ability to target opponents means we can commit a LOT of crimes in a short window, triggering Forsaken Miner over and over again.

With Viscera Seer (a Vampire) we can sacrifice it over and over, netting a ton of lifegain triggers, Vito triggers, etc. Viscera Seer conveniently helps with the Bolas's Citadel plan too.

If you really want to go infinite you can throw in Phyrexian Altar, but that's way out of the range for our budget considerations.

Rounding out Bracket 3, Wound Reflection ($2.17) really amps up the life loss for our opponents, and if played at the right moment, like after a big life-linking swing, can just take out opponents when they least expect it. I also really like Kaervek, the Punisher ($0.26) in this spot.

Again, Vito allows us to commit so many crimes plus the lifegain from the rest of our deck can offset the cost of casting spells from our graveyard. And finally, Witch of the Moors ($1.11) represents multiple four-for-ones, which can really help keep ahead of your opponents' resources.

 

Ultimately, the Bracket 3 package gives us a couple of late-game engines to help win the game, adds tutors and support to help get us there, and all for the low cost of $21.63

Wrap Up & Savings

This savings chart is going to look a little different than usual:

Bracket 4/BudgetPrice Bracket 3PriceBracket 2 Price 
Vampiric Tutor$43.74Aetherflux Reservoir$11.91Nirkana Revenant$6.38
Demonic Tutor$39.73Bolas's Citadel$4.10Bloodline Keeper$3.67
Bloodletter of Aclazotz$32.30Wound Reflection$2.17Captivating Vampire$0.95
Bloodthirsty Conqueror$30.82Witch of the Moors$1.11Kalastria Highborn$0.81
Exquisite Blood$17.89Mausoleum Secrets$0.69Drana, Liberator of Malakir$0.55
Cabal Coffers$15.63Viscera Seer$0.50Mask of Griselbrand$0.35
Alhammarret's Archive$13.70Lively Dirge$0.44Olivia's Wrath$0.28
Bloodchief Ascension$12.94Forsaken Miner$0.32Vampire Gourmand$0.23
Cabal Stronghold$10.47Kaervek, the Punisher$0.26Crossway Troublemakers$0.16
Black Market Connections$9.28Grim Servant$0.13Sanguine Syphoner$0.05
Sorin Markov$7.87
Total$234.37 Total$21.63Total$13.43
Original Deck Price $321.20New Price (Bracket 3)$108.46New Price (Bracket 2)$100.26
 Total Savings  Total Savings$212.74Total Savings220.94
   Savings %66%Savings %69%

 

It looks like we reach our usual level of savings by downgrading the brackets. The prices between 2 and 3 are not that much different, which I like to think shows how much the generic staples/game changers really inflate the cost of the deck.

Another way to look at this from a savings perspective is that you can spend an extra $20 and get everything you need to get your Bracket 4 deck able to break into two more decks! I like that idea, especially if you enjoy Vito enough that you'd like to play him all the time, regardless of power level.

So what do you think? Do you like or dislike the Bracket packages? Any other ideas for cards specifically for Vito? Let me know in the comments and I'll see you next time when we brew for your buck!

Bracket for Your Buck - Vito

Vito, Thorn of the Dusk Rose

Please note: card prices listed in this article are accurate at the time of writing, but prices can vary over time and between locations.

Brian Cain

Brian Cain

Brian started playing Magic in 2003, and played occasionally until 2017 when he finally embraced his love for Commander and never looked back. Ratadrabik of Urborg and The Gitrog Monster sit atop the list of his favorite decks, while Dread Return and Faithless Looting are among his favorite cards to cast. Outside of Magic, Brian works as an engineer in the marine industry, turning his love for ships into a career. He loves his growing family, the beach, and D&D

Want more Commander content, right in your inbox?

To stay on top of all our news, features, and deck techs, sign up for our EDHRECap e-mail newsletter.

EDHREC Code of Conduct

Your opinions are welcome. We love hearing what you think about Magic! We ask that you are always respectful when commenting. Please keep in mind how your comments could be interpreted by others. Personal attacks on our writers or other commenters will not be tolerated. Your comments may be removed if your language could be interpreted as aggressive or disrespectful. You may also be banned from writing further comments.