Chthonian Nightmare
Pitiless Plunderer
Parallel Lives

   Prerequisites

What do I need to start this combo?
All permanents on the battlefield.
You control another nontoken creature. You have a creature card in your graveyard. The total mana value of the creature on the battlefield and the creature card in your graveyard is at most 6.
You have at least eee.

   Steps

How does this combo work?
1
Activate Chthonian Nightmare by paying an amount of e, sacrificing a nontoken creature and returning Chthonian Nightmare from the battlefield to your hand.
2
When the creature dies, Pitiless Plunderer triggers, creating two Treasure tokens due to Parallel Lives.
3
Resolve the Chthonian Nightmare ability, returning another creature from your graveyard to the battlefield.
4
Activate two Treasures by tapping and sacrificing them, adding 1.
5
Cast Chthonian Nightmare by paying 1.
6
When Chthonian Nightmare enters, it triggers, causing you to get eee.
7
Repeat.

   Results

What do I get from this combo?
Infinite ETB
Infinite LTB
Infinite death triggers
Infinite energy counters
Infinite sacrifice triggers
Infinite storm count
Dina, Essence Brewer
0.0%inclusion2 decks7.52K decks
Top Commanders
Chatterfang, Squirrel General
0.4%inclusion117 decks26.1K decks
Korvold, Fae-Cursed King
0.4%inclusion77 decks19.9K decks
Prossh, Skyraider of Kher
0.3%inclusion20 decks6.88K decks
Ygra, Eater of All
0.1%inclusion19 decks22.6K decks
The Mycotyrant
0.1%inclusion13 decks9.21K decks
Slimefoot and Squee
0.2%inclusion13 decks8.44K decks
Ghave, Guru of Spores
0.1%inclusion11 decks7.82K decks
Slimefoot, the Stowaway
0.2%inclusion10 decks6.17K decks
Hazel of the Rootbloom
0.1%inclusion8 decks12.6K decks
Camellia, the Seedmiser
0.1%inclusion7 decks6.01K decks
Beledros Witherbloom
0.1%inclusion6 decks4.64K decks
Savra, Queen of the Golgari
0.1%inclusion5 decks4.80K decks
Nemata, Primeval Warden
0.4%inclusion5 decks1.32K decks
Teval, the Balanced Scale
0.0%inclusion5 decks33.5K decks
Hapatra, Vizier of Poisons
0.1%inclusion4 decks5.84K decks
Othelm, Sigardian Outcast // Wernog, Rider's Chaplain
0.4%inclusion4 decks1.12K decks
Sek'Kuar, Deathkeeper
0.2%inclusion4 decks1.77K decks
Ellie, Brick Master // Joel, Resolute Survivor
0.1%inclusion4 decks3.28K decks
Grist, Voracious Larva
0.1%inclusion3 decks3.02K decks
The Necrobloom
0.0%inclusion3 decks24.5K decks
Abby, Merciless Soldier // Ellie, Vengeful Hunter
0.3%inclusion3 decks932 decks
Meren of Clan Nel Toth
0.0%inclusion2 decks21.1K decks
Hogaak, Arisen Necropolis
0.1%inclusion2 decks2.71K decks
Old Rutstein
0.2%inclusion2 decks987 decks
New Cards
Cauldron of Essence
39%inclusion22 decks56 decks
Erode
20%inclusion1 decks5 decks
Fix What's Broken
20%inclusion1 decks5 decks
Smaug the Magnificent
13%inclusion2 decks15 decks
Immoral Bargain
12%inclusion7 decks59 decks
High Synergy Cards
Mayhem Devil
76%inclusion103 decks135 decks
Warren Soultrader
71%inclusion275 decks389 decks
Skullclamp
69%inclusion268 decks389 decks
Mirkwood Bats
62%inclusion241 decks389 decks
Ashnod's Altar
59%inclusion228 decks389 decks
Ignoble Hierarch
76%inclusion103 decks135 decks
Zulaport Cutthroat
56%inclusion216 decks389 decks
Chatterfang, Squirrel General
50%inclusion196 decks389 decks
Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth
52%inclusion204 decks389 decks
Academy Manufactor
47%inclusion183 decks389 decks
Top Cards
Swords to Plowshares
64%inclusion16 decks25 decks
Assassin's Trophy
62%inclusion240 decks389 decks
Birds of Paradise
54%inclusion209 decks389 decks
Blood Artist
51%inclusion199 decks389 decks
Heroic Intervention
51%inclusion198 decks389 decks
Tireless Provisioner
48%inclusion188 decks389 decks
Anointed Procession
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
Marionette Apprentice
46%inclusion178 decks389 decks
Kambal, Profiteering Mayor
44%inclusion11 decks25 decks
Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim
44%inclusion11 decks25 decks
Game Changers
Smothering Tithe
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
Demonic Tutor
32%inclusion125 decks389 decks
Aura Shards
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
Teferi's Protection
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
Enlightened Tutor
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
Vampiric Tutor
22%inclusion85 decks389 decks
Worldly Tutor
21%inclusion80 decks389 decks
Orcish Bowmasters
18%inclusion70 decks389 decks
Field of the Dead
17%inclusion65 decks389 decks
Crop Rotation
16%inclusion64 decks389 decks
Creatures
Viscera Seer
41%inclusion160 decks389 decks
Eternal Witness
40%inclusion156 decks389 decks
Rosie Cotton of South Lane
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
Exalted Sunborn
40%inclusion6 decks15 decks
Mahadi, Emporium Master
40%inclusion54 decks135 decks
Goldspan Dragon
37%inclusion50 decks135 decks
Mondrak, Glory Dominus
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
The Scarab God
36%inclusion5 decks14 decks
Peregrin Took
35%inclusion136 decks389 decks
Gilded Goose
35%inclusion135 decks389 decks
Nadier's Nightblade
34%inclusion132 decks389 decks
Sakura-Tribe Elder
33%inclusion129 decks389 decks
Esper Sentinel
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
Juri, Master of the Revue
31%inclusion42 decks135 decks
Xorn
30%inclusion41 decks135 decks
Braids, Arisen Nightmare
30%inclusion118 decks389 decks
Kheru Goldkeeper
30%inclusion3 decks10 decks
Yawgmoth, Thran Physician
29%inclusion114 decks389 decks
Professional Face-Breaker
29%inclusion39 decks135 decks
Wilhelt, the Rotcleaver
29%inclusion4 decks14 decks
Sidisi, Brood Tyrant
29%inclusion4 decks14 decks
Adrix and Nev, Twincasters
29%inclusion4 decks14 decks
Muldrotha, the Gravetide
29%inclusion4 decks14 decks
Corpse Knight
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
Delighted Halfling
26%inclusion103 decks389 decks
Toski, Bearer of Secrets
26%inclusion102 decks389 decks
Korvold, Fae-Cursed King
25%inclusion34 decks135 decks
Hazel of the Rootbloom
24%inclusion92 decks376 decks
Impulsive Pilferer
24%inclusion33 decks135 decks
Llanowar Elves
24%inclusion94 decks389 decks
Good-Fortune Unicorn
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
Bartolomé del Presidio
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
Ancient Copper Dragon
24%inclusion32 decks135 decks
Scute Swarm
24%inclusion92 decks389 decks
Jaheira, Friend of the Forest
23%inclusion91 decks389 decks
Camellia, the Seedmiser
23%inclusion87 decks376 decks
Squee, the Immortal
22%inclusion30 decks135 decks
Tendershoot Dryad
22%inclusion86 decks389 decks
Crime Novelist
21%inclusion29 decks135 decks
Diregraf Captain
21%inclusion3 decks14 decks
Wonder
21%inclusion3 decks14 decks
Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrath
21%inclusion3 decks14 decks
Sephiroth, Fabled SOLDIER
21%inclusion43 decks207 decks
Ziatora, the Incinerator
21%inclusion28 decks135 decks
Wight of the Reliquary
20%inclusion79 decks389 decks
Guide of Souls
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
Ocelot Pride
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
Samwise Gamgee
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
Purphoros, God of the Forge
20%inclusion27 decks135 decks
Teysa Karlov
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
Instants
Deadly Dispute
44%inclusion171 decks389 decks
Path to Exile
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
An Offer You Can't Refuse
36%inclusion5 decks14 decks
Generous Gift
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
Anguished Unmaking
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
Beast Within
32%inclusion123 decks389 decks
Deflecting Swat
29%inclusion39 decks135 decks
Sink into Stupor
29%inclusion4 decks14 decks
Deadly Rollick
23%inclusion90 decks389 decks
Dark Ritual
23%inclusion89 decks389 decks
Tear Asunder
22%inclusion84 decks389 decks
Arcane Denial
21%inclusion3 decks14 decks
Abrupt Decay
21%inclusion82 decks389 decks
Revitalizing Repast
21%inclusion81 decks389 decks
Artifact Mutation
20%inclusion27 decks135 decks
Saw in Half
19%inclusion74 decks389 decks
Second Harvest
19%inclusion73 decks389 decks
Chord of Calling
19%inclusion72 decks389 decks
Plumb the Forbidden
17%inclusion66 decks389 decks
Village Rites
17%inclusion66 decks389 decks
Dawn's Truce
17%inclusion4 decks24 decks
Malakir Rebirth
16%inclusion63 decks389 decks
Clever Concealment
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
Inkshield
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
Eladamri's Call
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
Chaos Warp
16%inclusion21 decks135 decks
Fell the Profane
15%inclusion59 decks389 decks
Veil of Summer
13%inclusion49 decks389 decks
Terminate
13%inclusion17 decks135 decks
Fateful Absence
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
Arachnogenesis
12%inclusion46 decks389 decks
Culling the Weak
11%inclusion42 decks389 decks
Putrefy
11%inclusion41 decks389 decks
Verdant Command
10%inclusion39 decks389 decks
Tibalt's Trickery
10%inclusion13 decks135 decks
Big Score
10%inclusion13 decks135 decks
Force of Vigor
9.0%inclusion35 decks389 decks
Harrow
9.0%inclusion35 decks389 decks
Noxious Revival
8.7%inclusion34 decks389 decks
Nature's Claim
8.5%inclusion33 decks389 decks
Pyroblast
8.1%inclusion11 decks135 decks
Red Elemental Blast
8.1%inclusion11 decks135 decks
Corrupted Conviction
6.9%inclusion27 decks389 decks
Golgari Charm
6.7%inclusion26 decks389 decks
Entomb
6.7%inclusion26 decks389 decks
Collective Resistance
6.4%inclusion25 decks389 decks
Tamiyo's Safekeeping
5.9%inclusion23 decks389 decks
Untimely Malfunction
5.9%inclusion6 decks102 decks
Dina's Guidance
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
Rakdos Charm
5.2%inclusion7 decks135 decks
Sorceries
Blasphemous Act
41%inclusion56 decks135 decks
Diabolic Intent
38%inclusion148 decks389 decks
Toxic Deluge
34%inclusion133 decks389 decks
Reanimate
34%inclusion133 decks389 decks
Nature's Lore
33%inclusion130 decks389 decks
Three Visits
31%inclusion119 decks389 decks
Farseek
29%inclusion111 decks389 decks
Victimize
27%inclusion106 decks389 decks
Culling Ritual
24%inclusion95 decks389 decks
Cultivate
21%inclusion82 decks389 decks
Pest Infestation
19%inclusion72 decks389 decks
Swarmyard Massacre
17%inclusion62 decks367 decks
Bala Ged Recovery
16%inclusion61 decks389 decks
Finale of Devastation
15%inclusion59 decks389 decks
Jeska's Will
15%inclusion20 decks135 decks
Eldritch Evolution
14%inclusion54 decks389 decks
Rampant Growth
13%inclusion52 decks389 decks
Blasphemous Edict
13%inclusion37 decks283 decks
Beseech the Mirror
12%inclusion48 decks389 decks
Damn
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
Kodama's Reach
12%inclusion45 decks389 decks
Dread Return
11%inclusion44 decks389 decks
Vandalblast
10%inclusion14 decks135 decks
Unearth
10%inclusion40 decks389 decks
Agadeem's Awakening
10%inclusion37 decks389 decks
Green Sun's Zenith
10%inclusion37 decks389 decks
Damnation
10%inclusion37 decks389 decks
Brass's Bounty
8.9%inclusion12 decks135 decks
Gamble
8.9%inclusion12 decks135 decks
Chandra's Ignition
8.1%inclusion11 decks135 decks
Chatterstorm
7.5%inclusion29 decks389 decks
Faithless Looting
7.4%inclusion10 decks135 decks
Torment of Hailfire
7.2%inclusion28 decks389 decks
Natural Order
6.9%inclusion27 decks389 decks
Flare of Cultivation
6.7%inclusion26 decks389 decks
Decimate
6.7%inclusion9 decks135 decks
Living Death
6.4%inclusion25 decks389 decks
Lich-Knights' Conquest
5.9%inclusion23 decks389 decks
Life from the Loam
5.9%inclusion23 decks389 decks
For the Common Good
5.9%inclusion22 decks375 decks
Awaken the Woods
5.7%inclusion22 decks389 decks
Rise of the Witch-king
5.7%inclusion22 decks389 decks
Shamanic Revelation
5.4%inclusion21 decks389 decks
Season of Loss
5.3%inclusion20 decks376 decks
Nature's Rhythm
5.2%inclusion12 decks233 decks
Many Partings
5.1%inclusion20 decks389 decks
Grim Tutor
5.1%inclusion20 decks389 decks
Buried Alive
5.1%inclusion20 decks389 decks
Utility Artifacts
Phyrexian Altar
41%inclusion158 decks389 decks
Lightning Greaves
34%inclusion134 decks389 decks
The Reaver Cleaver
24%inclusion33 decks135 decks
Nuka-Cola Vending Machine
22%inclusion87 decks389 decks
Chitterspitter
20%inclusion76 decks389 decks
Bootleggers' Stash
17%inclusion66 decks389 decks
Swiftfoot Boots
15%inclusion60 decks389 decks
Idol of Oblivion
14%inclusion55 decks389 decks
The One Ring
11%inclusion42 decks389 decks
Witch's Oven
11%inclusion41 decks389 decks
Altar of Dementia
10%inclusion38 decks389 decks
Bolas's Citadel
7.2%inclusion28 decks389 decks
Urabrask's Forge
5.9%inclusion8 decks135 decks
Eldrazi Monument
5.7%inclusion22 decks389 decks
Birthing Pod
5.1%inclusion20 decks389 decks
Enchantments
Goblin Bombardment
44%inclusion59 decks135 decks
Doubling Season
42%inclusion163 decks389 decks
Bastion of Remembrance
37%inclusion144 decks389 decks
Titans' Nest
36%inclusion5 decks14 decks
The Meathook Massacre
34%inclusion134 decks389 decks
Black Market Connections
31%inclusion122 decks389 decks
Insidious Roots
27%inclusion106 decks389 decks
Impact Tremors
27%inclusion36 decks135 decks
Grave Pact
26%inclusion103 decks389 decks
Moldervine Reclamation
23%inclusion89 decks389 decks
Kindred Discovery
21%inclusion3 decks14 decks
Rhystic Study
21%inclusion3 decks14 decks
Caretaker's Talent
21%inclusion5 decks24 decks
Cathars' Crusade
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
Sylvan Library
20%inclusion77 decks389 decks
Bitterblossom
19%inclusion75 decks389 decks
Dictate of Erebos
19%inclusion72 decks389 decks
Growing Rites of Itlimoc
18%inclusion71 decks389 decks
Squirrel Nest
17%inclusion68 decks389 decks
Rhythm of the Wild
16%inclusion21 decks135 decks
Beastmaster Ascension
14%inclusion56 decks389 decks
Awakening Zone
14%inclusion55 decks389 decks
Cryptolith Rite
14%inclusion55 decks389 decks
Dazzling Theater // Prop Room
14%inclusion3 decks22 decks
Revel in Riches
13%inclusion52 decks389 decks
Scavenger's Talent
13%inclusion49 decks372 decks
Earthcraft
13%inclusion50 decks389 decks
Alchemist's Talent
11%inclusion14 decks127 decks
Animate Dead
11%inclusion42 decks389 decks
Funeral Room // Awakening Hall
11%inclusion34 decks316 decks
Wild Growth
10%inclusion37 decks389 decks
Ninja Pizza
9.4%inclusion8 decks85 decks
Utopia Sprawl
8.7%inclusion34 decks389 decks
Ripples of Undeath
8.0%inclusion31 decks389 decks
Fecundity
7.2%inclusion28 decks389 decks
Carpet of Flowers
7.2%inclusion28 decks389 decks
Phyrexian Arena
7.2%inclusion28 decks389 decks
Primal Vigor
6.9%inclusion27 decks389 decks
Night of the Sweets' Revenge
6.7%inclusion26 decks389 decks
Necropotence
6.7%inclusion26 decks389 decks
Rain of Riches
6.7%inclusion9 decks135 decks
Descent into Avernus
6.7%inclusion9 decks135 decks
Agent of the Iron Throne
6.4%inclusion25 decks389 decks
Stimulus Package
5.9%inclusion8 decks135 decks
Fable of the Mirror-Breaker
5.9%inclusion8 decks135 decks
Vampiric Rites
5.7%inclusion22 decks389 decks
Defense of the Heart
5.7%inclusion22 decks389 decks
Springleaf Parade
5.5%inclusion6 decks110 decks
Food Chain
5.4%inclusion21 decks389 decks
Aggravated Assault
5.2%inclusion7 decks135 decks
Planeswalkers
Elspeth, Storm Slayer
35%inclusion6 decks17 decks
Liliana, Dreadhorde General
19%inclusion75 decks389 decks
Grist, the Hunger Tide
7.2%inclusion28 decks389 decks
Garruk, Cursed Huntsman
6.9%inclusion27 decks389 decks
Xenagos, the Reveler
5.9%inclusion8 decks135 decks
Vraska, Golgari Queen
5.1%inclusion20 decks389 decks
Tyvar, Jubilant Brawler
5.1%inclusion20 decks389 decks
Utility Lands
Phyrexian Tower
52%inclusion203 decks389 decks
Bojuka Bog
41%inclusion159 decks389 decks
Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth
40%inclusion157 decks389 decks
Boseiju, Who Endures
35%inclusion135 decks389 decks
Swarmyard
29%inclusion111 decks389 decks
Reliquary Tower
25%inclusion99 decks389 decks
The Shire
23%inclusion91 decks389 decks
Shifting Woodland
23%inclusion90 decks389 decks
Otawara, Soaring City
21%inclusion3 decks14 decks
Takenuma, Abandoned Mire
20%inclusion77 decks389 decks
Three Tree City
19%inclusion72 decks376 decks
Fountainport
18%inclusion68 decks371 decks
Spymaster's Vault
15%inclusion59 decks389 decks
Ancient Tomb
15%inclusion58 decks389 decks
Urza's Saga
14%inclusion53 decks389 decks
Cabal Coffers
13%inclusion51 decks389 decks
Evendo, Waking Haven
13%inclusion24 decks184 decks
Treasure Vault
13%inclusion49 decks389 decks
Rogue's Passage
13%inclusion49 decks389 decks
Gavony Township
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
Kher Keep
12%inclusion16 decks135 decks
High Market
12%inclusion46 decks389 decks
Gaea's Cradle
12%inclusion45 decks389 decks
Gingerbread Cabin
10%inclusion40 decks389 decks
Grim Backwoods
10%inclusion38 decks389 decks
Dryad Arbor
10%inclusion37 decks389 decks
Khalni Garden
9.3%inclusion36 decks389 decks
Restless Cottage
9.3%inclusion36 decks389 decks
Kessig Wolf Run
8.9%inclusion12 decks135 decks
Westvale Abbey
8.5%inclusion33 decks389 decks
Oran-Rief, the Vastwood
8.5%inclusion33 decks389 decks
Oakhollow Village
7.6%inclusion29 decks382 decks
Sokenzan, Crucible of Defiance
7.4%inclusion10 decks135 decks
Arena of Glory
7.4%inclusion10 decks135 decks
Mudflat Village
7.1%inclusion27 decks381 decks
Strip Mine
5.9%inclusion23 decks389 decks
Midgar, City of Mako
5.9%inclusion12 decks204 decks
Mana Artifacts
Sol Ring
89%inclusion346 decks389 decks
Arcane Signet
67%inclusion262 decks389 decks
Talisman of Curiosity
21%inclusion3 decks14 decks
Talisman of Dominance
21%inclusion3 decks14 decks
Talisman of Resilience
20%inclusion78 decks389 decks
Talisman of Hierarchy
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
Talisman of Unity
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
Golgari Signet
13%inclusion51 decks389 decks
Talisman of Indulgence
10%inclusion14 decks135 decks
Fellwar Stone
9.0%inclusion35 decks389 decks
Lotus Petal
8.2%inclusion32 decks389 decks
Talisman of Impulse
8.1%inclusion11 decks135 decks
Thought Vessel
6.2%inclusion24 decks389 decks
Mana Crypt
5.9%inclusion23 decks389 decks
Lands
Command Tower
92%inclusion358 decks389 decks
Watery Grave
79%inclusion11 decks14 decks
Breeding Pool
79%inclusion11 decks14 decks
Overgrown Tomb
77%inclusion301 decks389 decks
Temple Garden
76%inclusion19 decks25 decks
Stomping Ground
76%inclusion102 decks135 decks
Ziatora's Proving Ground
73%inclusion98 decks135 decks
Blood Crypt
71%inclusion96 decks135 decks
Godless Shrine
68%inclusion17 decks25 decks
Zagoth Triome
64%inclusion9 decks14 decks
Indatha Triome
60%inclusion15 decks25 decks
Verdant Catacombs
60%inclusion232 decks389 decks
Woodland Cemetery
59%inclusion228 decks389 decks
Undergrowth Stadium
56%inclusion216 decks389 decks
Bountiful Promenade
52%inclusion13 decks25 decks
Llanowar Wastes
50%inclusion195 decks389 decks
Morphic Pool
50%inclusion7 decks14 decks
Vault of Champions
44%inclusion11 decks25 decks
Luxury Suite
43%inclusion58 decks135 decks
Undercity Sewers
43%inclusion6 decks14 decks
Drowned Catacomb
43%inclusion6 decks14 decks
Hinterland Harbor
43%inclusion6 decks14 decks
Spire Garden
42%inclusion57 decks135 decks
Exotic Orchard
38%inclusion146 decks389 decks
Deathcap Glade
37%inclusion143 decks389 decks
Twilight Mire
37%inclusion143 decks389 decks
Canopy Vista
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
Wooded Foothills
36%inclusion139 decks389 decks
Foreboding Landscape
36%inclusion5 decks14 decks
Hedge Maze
36%inclusion5 decks14 decks
Rejuvenating Springs
36%inclusion5 decks14 decks
Opulent Palace
36%inclusion5 decks14 decks
Dragonskull Summit
36%inclusion48 decks135 decks
Bloodstained Mire
34%inclusion133 decks389 decks
Rootbound Crag
33%inclusion45 decks135 decks
Underground Mortuary
30%inclusion115 decks389 decks
Underground River
29%inclusion4 decks14 decks
Yavimaya Coast
29%inclusion4 decks14 decks
Fabled Passage
28%inclusion109 decks389 decks
Brushland
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
Sandsteppe Citadel
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
Rockfall Vale
26%inclusion35 decks135 decks
Twisted Landscape
25%inclusion34 decks135 decks
Windswept Heath
25%inclusion96 decks389 decks
Cinder Glade
24%inclusion33 decks135 decks
Sunpetal Grove
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
Caves of Koilos
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
Isolated Chapel
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
Wastewood Verge
23%inclusion60 decks257 decks
Karplusan Forest
23%inclusion31 decks135 decks