Ashnod's Altar
Restless Apparition
Thran Vigil

   Prerequisites

What do I need to start this combo?
All permanents on the battlefield (Restless Apparition without a -1/-1 counter on it on the battlefield).

   Steps

How does this combo work?
1
Activate Ashnod's Altar by sacrificing Restless Apparition.
2
When Restless Apparition dies, its persist ability triggers, returning it from your graveyard to the battlefield with a -1/-1 counter on it.
3
Thran Vigil triggers, putting a +1/+1 counter on Restless Apparition.
4
Repeat.

   Results

What do I get from this combo?
Infinite ETB
Infinite LTB
Infinite colorless mana
Infinite death triggers
Infinite sacrifice triggers
Celes, Rune Knight
1.1%inclusion110 decks9.63K decks
Tayam, Luminous Enigma
0.3%inclusion23 decks8.20K decks
Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim
0.1%inclusion9 decks8.08K decks
Bartolomé del Presidio
0.5%inclusion9 decks1.71K decks
Teysa Karlov
0.0%inclusion4 decks20.2K decks
Eirdu, Carrier of Dawn
0.1%inclusion4 decks4.40K decks
Teysa, Orzhov Scion
0.0%inclusion2 decks4.08K decks
Athreos, God of Passage
0.0%inclusion2 decks8.50K decks
Lurrus of the Dream-Den
0.1%inclusion2 decks2.80K decks
Mr. House, President and CEO
0.0%inclusion2 decks21.3K decks
Karador, Ghost Chieftain
0.0%inclusion2 decks6.37K decks
Alharu, Solemn Ritualist // Tormod, the Desecrator
17%inclusion2 decks12 decks
Zur the Enchanter
0.0%inclusion1 decks15.4K decks
Nevinyrral, Urborg Tyrant
0.1%inclusion1 decks1.92K decks
Bane, Lord of Darkness
0.0%inclusion1 decks2.39K decks
Alesha, Who Smiles at Death
0.0%inclusion1 decks5.84K decks
Ghave, Guru of Spores
0.0%inclusion1 decks7.68K decks
Rukarumel, Biologist
0.0%inclusion1 decks4.16K decks
New Cards
Cauldron of Essence
50%inclusion3 decks6 decks
Gorma, the Gullet
29%inclusion2 decks7 decks
Hardened Academic
13%inclusion3 decks24 decks
Grave Researcher
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
Flashback
4.2%inclusion1 decks24 decks
High Synergy Cards
Murderous Redcap
96%inclusion116 decks121 decks
Safehold Elite
94%inclusion33 decks35 decks
Putrid Goblin
93%inclusion175 decks188 decks
Kitchen Finks
89%inclusion31 decks35 decks
Rendclaw Trow
83%inclusion29 decks35 decks
Goblin Bombardment
88%inclusion106 decks121 decks
Obstinate Gargoyle
81%inclusion151 decks187 decks
Lesser Masticore
78%inclusion146 decks188 decks
Viscera Seer
81%inclusion153 decks188 decks
Good-Fortune Unicorn
71%inclusion25 decks35 decks
Top Cards
Carrion Feeder
71%inclusion134 decks188 decks
Swords to Plowshares
66%inclusion124 decks188 decks
Grumgully, the Generous
63%inclusion5 decks8 decks
Zulaport Cutthroat
61%inclusion114 decks188 decks
Blood Artist
60%inclusion112 decks188 decks
Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim
59%inclusion110 decks188 decks
Glen Elendra Archmage
58%inclusion7 decks12 decks
Devoted Druid
57%inclusion20 decks35 decks
Altar of Dementia
55%inclusion104 decks188 decks
Phyrexian Altar
53%inclusion99 decks188 decks
Game Changers
Demonic Tutor
30%inclusion57 decks188 decks
Vampiric Tutor
26%inclusion48 decks188 decks
Underworld Breach
19%inclusion23 decks121 decks
Gamble
18%inclusion22 decks121 decks
Enlightened Tutor
18%inclusion34 decks188 decks
Gaea's Cradle
11%inclusion4 decks35 decks
Bolas's Citadel
10%inclusion18 decks188 decks
Necropotence
8.0%inclusion15 decks188 decks
Chrome Mox
8.0%inclusion15 decks188 decks
Imperial Seal
6.9%inclusion13 decks188 decks
Creatures
Puppeteer Clique
51%inclusion96 decks188 decks
River Kelpie
50%inclusion6 decks12 decks
Umbral Collar Zealot
49%inclusion66 decks135 decks
Mayhem Devil
46%inclusion56 decks121 decks
Bartolomé del Presidio
43%inclusion81 decks188 decks
Lingering Tormentor
41%inclusion78 decks188 decks
Pitiless Plunderer
41%inclusion77 decks188 decks
Wingrattle Scarecrow
38%inclusion72 decks188 decks
Molten Gatekeeper
38%inclusion46 decks121 decks
Cruel Celebrant
38%inclusion71 decks188 decks
Grazing Kelpie
38%inclusion3 decks8 decks
Heartmender
37%inclusion13 decks35 decks
Strangleroot Geist
37%inclusion13 decks35 decks
Melira, Sylvok Outcast
37%inclusion13 decks35 decks
Young Wolf
34%inclusion12 decks35 decks
Luminous Broodmoth
33%inclusion62 decks188 decks
Warren Soultrader
33%inclusion61 decks187 decks
Rishkar, Peema Renegade
31%inclusion11 decks35 decks
Eternal Witness
31%inclusion11 decks35 decks
Birds of Paradise
31%inclusion11 decks35 decks
Vizier of Remedies
29%inclusion54 decks188 decks
Renata, Called to the Hunt
29%inclusion10 decks35 decks
Grand Abolisher
27%inclusion51 decks188 decks
Esper Sentinel
27%inclusion51 decks188 decks
Gev, Scaled Scorch
26%inclusion32 decks121 decks
Imperial Recruiter
26%inclusion32 decks121 decks
Kithkin Spellduster
26%inclusion49 decks188 decks
Gravelgill Axeshark
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks
Nardole, Resourceful Cyborg
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks
Warden of the Grove
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
Priest of Fell Rites
23%inclusion44 decks188 decks
Aerie Ouphes
23%inclusion8 decks35 decks
Juniper Order Ranger
23%inclusion8 decks35 decks
Ivy Lane Denizen
23%inclusion8 decks35 decks
Arwen, Weaver of Hope
23%inclusion8 decks35 decks
Avacyn's Pilgrim
23%inclusion8 decks35 decks
Persistent Constrictor
23%inclusion42 decks184 decks
Voice of Victory
22%inclusion37 decks165 decks
Tromell, Seymour's Butler
22%inclusion5 decks23 decks
Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff
21%inclusion39 decks188 decks
Furystoke Giant
21%inclusion25 decks121 decks
Eirdu, Carrier of Dawn
20%inclusion24 decks118 decks
Corpse Knight
20%inclusion38 decks188 decks
Morbid Opportunist
20%inclusion38 decks188 decks
Woodfall Primus
20%inclusion7 decks35 decks
Wall of Roots
20%inclusion7 decks35 decks
Basking Broodscale
20%inclusion7 decks35 decks
Sakura-Tribe Elder
20%inclusion7 decks35 decks
Terra, Herald of Hope
20%inclusion23 decks116 decks
Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate
18%inclusion22 decks121 decks
Instants
Path to Exile
52%inclusion98 decks188 decks
First Day of Class
51%inclusion62 decks121 decks
Dark Ritual
51%inclusion95 decks188 decks
Counterspell
33%inclusion4 decks12 decks
Cloudshift
31%inclusion58 decks188 decks
Ephemerate
31%inclusion58 decks188 decks
Deflecting Swat
31%inclusion37 decks121 decks
Anguished Unmaking
29%inclusion55 decks188 decks
Dovin's Veto
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks
Deadly Dispute
23%inclusion43 decks188 decks
Cauldron Haze
22%inclusion42 decks188 decks
Village Rites
21%inclusion40 decks188 decks
Deadly Rollick
21%inclusion39 decks188 decks
Thrill of Possibility
21%inclusion25 decks121 decks
Silence
20%inclusion38 decks188 decks
Assassin's Trophy
20%inclusion7 decks35 decks
Entomb
20%inclusion37 decks188 decks
Generous Gift
18%inclusion33 decks188 decks
Burnt Offering
16%inclusion19 decks121 decks
Flicker of Fate
15%inclusion29 decks188 decks
Red Elemental Blast
15%inclusion18 decks121 decks
Heroic Intervention
14%inclusion5 decks35 decks
Pyroblast
14%inclusion17 decks121 decks
Chaos Warp
14%inclusion17 decks121 decks
Reprieve
14%inclusion26 decks188 decks
Culling the Weak
14%inclusion26 decks188 decks
Mortify
13%inclusion25 decks188 decks
Despark
12%inclusion22 decks188 decks
Eladamri's Call
11%inclusion4 decks35 decks
Abrupt Decay
11%inclusion4 decks35 decks
Laughing Mad
11%inclusion12 decks108 decks
Redirect Lightning
11%inclusion10 decks90 decks
Boros Charm
11%inclusion13 decks121 decks
Corrupted Conviction
11%inclusion20 decks188 decks
Teferi's Protection
11%inclusion20 decks188 decks
Malakir Rebirth
10%inclusion19 decks188 decks
Cabal Ritual
10%inclusion18 decks188 decks
Stroke of Midnight
10%inclusion18 decks188 decks
Bolt Bend
9.1%inclusion11 decks121 decks
Wear // Tear
9.1%inclusion11 decks121 decks
Crackling Doom
9.1%inclusion11 decks121 decks
Untimely Malfunction
9.1%inclusion11 decks121 decks
Abrade
9.1%inclusion11 decks121 decks
Bedevil
9.1%inclusion11 decks121 decks
Parting Gust
8.6%inclusion16 decks185 decks
Obscuring Haze
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Chord of Calling
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Beast Within
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Not Dead After All
7.4%inclusion14 decks188 decks
Saw in Half
7.4%inclusion14 decks188 decks
Sorceries
Reanimate
43%inclusion81 decks188 decks
Sevinne's Reclamation
36%inclusion68 decks188 decks
Victimize
35%inclusion65 decks188 decks
Nature's Lore
34%inclusion12 decks35 decks
Faithless Looting
31%inclusion38 decks121 decks
Diabolic Intent
28%inclusion52 decks188 decks
Unearth
27%inclusion51 decks188 decks
Farseek
26%inclusion9 decks35 decks
Damn
25%inclusion47 decks188 decks
Persist
24%inclusion46 decks188 decks
Buried Alive
24%inclusion45 decks188 decks
Toxic Deluge
22%inclusion41 decks188 decks
Blasphemous Act
21%inclusion25 decks121 decks
Rampant Growth
20%inclusion7 decks35 decks
Stitch Together
20%inclusion37 decks188 decks
Lively Dirge
18%inclusion34 decks188 decks
Jeska's Will
16%inclusion19 decks121 decks
Ruinous Ultimatum
16%inclusion19 decks121 decks
Night's Whisper
13%inclusion25 decks188 decks
Diabolic Tutor
13%inclusion24 decks188 decks
Vandalblast
12%inclusion15 decks121 decks
Nature's Rhythm
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
Grim Tutor
12%inclusion22 decks188 decks
Green Sun's Zenith
11%inclusion4 decks35 decks
Three Visits
11%inclusion4 decks35 decks
Kodama's Reach
11%inclusion4 decks35 decks
Cultivate
11%inclusion4 decks35 decks
Dread Return
11%inclusion21 decks188 decks
Tempt with Discovery
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Finale of Devastation
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Eerie Ultimatum
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Profane Tutor
7.4%inclusion14 decks188 decks
Beseech the Mirror
7.4%inclusion14 decks188 decks
Wheel of Fortune
7.4%inclusion9 decks121 decks
Day of Judgment
6.9%inclusion13 decks188 decks
Unmarked Grave
6.9%inclusion13 decks188 decks
Demonic Counsel
6.5%inclusion12 decks184 decks
Rite of Oblivion
5.9%inclusion11 decks188 decks
Insatiable Avarice
5.9%inclusion11 decks188 decks
Mythos of Snapdax
5.8%inclusion7 decks121 decks
Cathartic Reunion
5.8%inclusion7 decks121 decks
Helping Hand
5.3%inclusion10 decks188 decks
Unburial Rites
5.3%inclusion10 decks188 decks
Sign in Blood
5.3%inclusion10 decks188 decks
Feed the Swarm
5.3%inclusion10 decks188 decks
Utility Artifacts
Blasting Station
49%inclusion93 decks188 decks
Cauldron of Souls
20%inclusion38 decks188 decks
Skullclamp
19%inclusion35 decks188 decks
Lightning Greaves
16%inclusion30 decks188 decks
Swiftfoot Boots
13%inclusion24 decks188 decks
The Great Henge
11%inclusion4 decks35 decks
Wishclaw Talisman
11%inclusion21 decks188 decks
Thunderous Velocipede
10%inclusion3 decks29 decks
Phoenix Down
8.6%inclusion13 decks152 decks
Spawning Pit
8.0%inclusion15 decks188 decks
The One Ring
6.9%inclusion13 decks188 decks
Enchantments
Master Chef
51%inclusion18 decks35 decks
Impact Tremors
51%inclusion62 decks121 decks
Rhythm of the Wild
50%inclusion4 decks8 decks
Bastion of Remembrance
38%inclusion72 decks188 decks
Animate Dead
27%inclusion51 decks188 decks
Abzan Ascendancy
23%inclusion8 decks35 decks
Cryptolith Rite
23%inclusion8 decks35 decks
Insidious Roots
23%inclusion8 decks35 decks
Solemnity
19%inclusion36 decks188 decks
The Meathook Massacre
16%inclusion31 decks188 decks
Phyrexian Arena
16%inclusion30 decks188 decks
Cathars' Crusade
14%inclusion27 decks188 decks
Hardened Scales
14%inclusion5 decks35 decks
Necromancy
13%inclusion24 decks188 decks
Smothering Tithe
13%inclusion24 decks188 decks
Black Market Connections
12%inclusion23 decks188 decks
Hollowmurk Siege
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
Sylvan Library
11%inclusion4 decks35 decks
Wild Growth
11%inclusion4 decks35 decks
Warleader's Call
11%inclusion13 decks121 decks
Touch the Spirit Realm
10%inclusion18 decks188 decks
Fecundity
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Kenrith's Transformation
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Tribute to the World Tree
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Utopia Sprawl
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Grave Pact
8.0%inclusion15 decks188 decks
Ripples of Undeath
7.5%inclusion14 decks187 decks
Dance of the Dead
7.4%inclusion14 decks188 decks
Promise of Bunrei
6.9%inclusion13 decks188 decks
Martyr's Cause
6.4%inclusion12 decks188 decks
Dictate of Erebos
6.4%inclusion12 decks188 decks
Land Tax
5.3%inclusion10 decks188 decks
Planeswalkers
Tyvar, Jubilant Brawler
20%inclusion7 decks35 decks
Utility Lands
Phyrexian Tower
20%inclusion38 decks188 decks
Bojuka Bog
20%inclusion38 decks188 decks
Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth
19%inclusion36 decks188 decks
Boseiju, Who Endures
17%inclusion6 decks35 decks
Reliquary Tower
13%inclusion25 decks188 decks
High Market
12%inclusion23 decks188 decks
Gavony Township
11%inclusion4 decks35 decks
Rogue's Passage
11%inclusion21 decks188 decks
Ancient Tomb
10%inclusion18 decks188 decks
Takenuma, Abandoned Mire
9.0%inclusion17 decks188 decks
Hashep Oasis
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Grim Backwoods
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Oran-Rief, the Vastwood
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Shifting Woodland
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Mortuary Mire
6.9%inclusion13 decks188 decks
Urza's Saga
5.3%inclusion10 decks188 decks
Vault of the Archangel
5.3%inclusion10 decks188 decks
Mana Artifacts
Sol Ring
87%inclusion164 decks188 decks
Arcane Signet
84%inclusion158 decks188 decks
Talisman of Indulgence
66%inclusion80 decks121 decks
Talisman of Conviction
64%inclusion77 decks121 decks
Talisman of Hierarchy
54%inclusion101 decks188 decks
Talisman of Dominance
33%inclusion4 decks12 decks
Fellwar Stone
31%inclusion59 decks188 decks
Orzhov Signet
26%inclusion48 decks188 decks
Talisman of Progress
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks
Talisman of Unity
17%inclusion6 decks35 decks
Rakdos Signet
17%inclusion20 decks121 decks
Lotus Petal
15%inclusion29 decks188 decks
Boros Signet
12%inclusion15 decks121 decks
Talisman of Resilience
11%inclusion4 decks35 decks
Mind Stone
11%inclusion20 decks188 decks
Golgari Signet
8.6%inclusion3 decks35 decks
Thought Vessel
6.9%inclusion13 decks188 decks
Chromatic Lantern
6.4%inclusion12 decks188 decks
Commander's Sphere
5.9%inclusion11 decks188 decks
Mana Vault
5.3%inclusion10 decks188 decks
Lands
Command Tower
92%inclusion173 decks188 decks
Clifftop Retreat
56%inclusion68 decks121 decks
Sacred Foundry
56%inclusion68 decks121 decks
Isolated Chapel
55%inclusion103 decks188 decks
Sulfurous Springs
55%inclusion66 decks121 decks
Dragonskull Summit
55%inclusion66 decks121 decks
Exotic Orchard
54%inclusion102 decks188 decks
Nomad Outpost
52%inclusion63 decks121 decks
Blood Crypt
51%inclusion62 decks121 decks
Battlefield Forge
50%inclusion61 decks121 decks
Arcane Sanctum
50%inclusion6 decks12 decks
Breeding Pool
50%inclusion4 decks8 decks
Godless Shrine
48%inclusion90 decks188 decks
Caves of Koilos
47%inclusion89 decks188 decks
Hallowed Fountain
42%inclusion5 decks12 decks
Sandsteppe Citadel
40%inclusion14 decks35 decks
Woodland Cemetery
40%inclusion14 decks35 decks
Raugrin Triome
38%inclusion3 decks8 decks
The World Tree
38%inclusion3 decks8 decks
Jetmir's Garden
38%inclusion3 decks8 decks
Jungle Shrine
38%inclusion3 decks8 decks
Llanowar Wastes
37%inclusion13 decks35 decks
Temple Garden
37%inclusion13 decks35 decks
Smoldering Marsh
36%inclusion44 decks121 decks
Marsh Flats
36%inclusion67 decks188 decks
Vault of Champions
35%inclusion66 decks188 decks
Indatha Triome
34%inclusion12 decks35 decks
Sunpetal Grove
34%inclusion12 decks35 decks
Overgrown Tomb
34%inclusion12 decks35 decks
Raffine's Tower
33%inclusion4 decks12 decks
Watery Grave
33%inclusion4 decks12 decks
Luxury Suite
32%inclusion39 decks121 decks
Spectator Seating
31%inclusion37 decks121 decks
Fetid Heath
30%inclusion57 decks188 decks
Bloodstained Mire
29%inclusion55 decks188 decks
Savai Triome
29%inclusion35 decks121 decks
Rugged Prairie
26%inclusion32 decks121 decks
Undergrowth Stadium
26%inclusion9 decks35 decks
Foreboding Ruins
26%inclusion31 decks121 decks
Arid Mesa
26%inclusion48 decks188 decks
Shineshadow Snarl
26%inclusion48 decks188 decks
Azorius Chancery
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks
Dimir Aqueduct
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks
Tundra
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks
Underground Sea
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks
Deserted Beach
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks
Shipwreck Marsh
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks
Underground River
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks
Sea of Clouds
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks
Adarkar Wastes
25%inclusion3 decks12 decks