Bill the Pony (Commander) - Lifegain

Kyle Massa
Jul 11, 2024
The Over/Under - A Review of The Lord of the Rings Commanders
Which Lord of the Rings commanders have been most popular in practice? Kyle reviews his predictions one year on!
Deck Filters
Archidekt
Commander Spellbook
Moxfield
Scryfall
MTGStocks
Card KingdomCard Kingdom
Rosie Cotton of South Lane
85% of 59 decks +81% synergy
Eastfarthing Farmer
75% of 59 decks +74% synergy
Academy Manufactor
73% of 60 decks +72% synergy
Crested Sunmare
73% of 60 decks +71% synergy
Late to Dinner
72% of 60 decks +70% synergy
The Battle of Bywater
75% of 59 decks +70% synergy
The Gaffer
75% of 59 decks +69% synergy
Of Herbs and Stewed Rabbit
63% of 59 decks +61% synergy
Apothecary White
62% of 24 decks +61% synergy
Lembas
63% of 59 decks +59% synergy
Top Cards
Swords to Plowshares
82% of 60 decks +3% synergy
Path to Exile
68% of 60 decks +1% synergy
Daxos, Blessed by the Sun
63% of 60 decks +51% synergy
Astrid Peth
60% of 43 decks +59% synergy
Sierra, Nuka's Biggest Fan
59% of 22 decks +58% synergy
Stoneskin
58% of 60 decks +54% synergy
Nyx-Fleece Ram
57% of 60 decks +55% synergy
Teleportation Circle
55% of 60 decks +43% synergy
Ephemerate
55% of 60 decks +41% synergy
Field-Tested Frying Pan
51% of 59 decks +50% synergy
Creatures
Witch Enchanter
46% of 13 decks +19% synergy
Nykthos Paragon
43% of 60 decks +38% synergy
Gilraen, Dúnedain Protector
42% of 59 decks +39% synergy
Diamond Mare
40% of 60 decks +39% synergy
Soul Warden
40% of 60 decks +19% synergy
Solemn Simulacrum
40% of 60 decks +15% synergy
Baldin, Century Herdmaster
38% of 60 decks +37% synergy
Knight of the White Orchid
38% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Phelia, Exuberant Shepherd
36% of 14 decks +27% synergy
Zetalpa, Primal Dawn
35% of 60 decks +32% synergy
Rasaad yn Bashir
33% of 60 decks +33% synergy
Felidar Sovereign
33% of 60 decks +28% synergy
Syr Ginger, the Meal Ender
31% of 45 decks +30% synergy
Felidar Guardian
30% of 60 decks +21% synergy
Fortune, Loyal Steed
29% of 17 decks +24% synergy
Distinguished Conjurer
28% of 60 decks +22% synergy
Welcoming Vampire
28% of 60 decks +10% synergy
Mentor of the Meek
28% of 60 decks +3% synergy
Bartered Cow
27% of 60 decks +27% synergy
Rhox Faithmender
27% of 60 decks +23% synergy
Wall of Omens
27% of 60 decks +15% synergy
Sun Titan
27% of 60 decks -3% synergy
Eldrazi Displacer
25% of 60 decks +21% synergy
Restoration Angel
25% of 60 decks +16% synergy
Soul's Attendant
25% of 60 decks +11% synergy
Looming Altisaur
23% of 60 decks +23% synergy
Giant Ox
23% of 60 decks +22% synergy
Spirited Companion
23% of 60 decks +9% synergy
Weathered Wayfarer
23% of 60 decks +7% synergy
Esper Sentinel
23% of 60 decks -17% synergy
Mother of Runes
22% of 60 decks -2% synergy
Indomitable Ancients
20% of 60 decks +20% synergy
Delney, Streetwise Lookout
19% of 26 decks +12% synergy
Gwaihir, Greatest of the Eagles
19% of 59 decks +17% synergy
Samwise the Stouthearted
19% of 59 decks +15% synergy
Flickerwisp
18% of 60 decks +10% synergy
Charming Prince
18% of 60 decks +8% synergy
Loran of the Third Path
18% of 60 decks -5% synergy
Nimble Hobbit
17% of 59 decks +17% synergy
Harnessed Snubhorn
17% of 59 decks +16% synergy
Oathsworn Giant
17% of 60 decks +16% synergy
Mondrak, Glory Dominus
17% of 60 decks +2% synergy
Suture Priest
17% of 60 decks +1% synergy
Essence of Antiquity
16% of 25 decks +15% synergy
Gandalf the White
15% of 59 decks +13% synergy
Kami of Old Stone
15% of 60 decks +15% synergy
Pegasus Guardian
15% of 60 decks +14% synergy
Serra Avatar
15% of 60 decks +13% synergy
Dawnbringer Cleric
15% of 60 decks +12% synergy
Speaker of the Heavens
15% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Instants
Second Breakfast
42% of 59 decks +42% synergy
Generous Gift
42% of 60 decks -7% synergy
Aegis of the Heavens
40% of 60 decks +40% synergy
Refuse to Yield
38% of 60 decks +38% synergy
Cloudshift
38% of 60 decks +28% synergy
Reprieve
37% of 59 decks +17% synergy
Hobbit's Sting
36% of 59 decks +35% synergy
Razorgrass Ambush
33% of 12 decks +20% synergy
Flicker of Fate
28% of 60 decks +23% synergy
Disenchant
27% of 60 decks +9% synergy
Stroke of Midnight
27% of 45 decks -2% synergy
Slip On the Ring
25% of 59 decks +22% synergy
Bar the Door
23% of 60 decks +23% synergy
Flare of Fortitude
23% of 13 decks -4% synergy
Eerie Interlude
22% of 60 decks +11% synergy
Enlightened Tutor
17% of 60 decks -10% synergy
Sejiri Shelter
15% of 60 decks +2% synergy
Get Lost
14% of 35 decks +3% synergy
Wings of the Cosmos
13% of 60 decks +13% synergy
Solidarity
13% of 60 decks +13% synergy
Flawless Maneuver
13% of 60 decks -12% synergy
Teferi's Protection
13% of 60 decks -20% synergy
Scrollshift
12% of 59 decks +8% synergy
Escape from Orthanc
10% of 49 decks +10% synergy
Revitalize
10% of 60 decks +7% synergy
Your Temple Is Under Attack
10% of 60 decks +1% synergy
Heliod's Intervention
10% of 60 decks -4% synergy
Unbreakable Formation
10% of 60 decks -5% synergy
Iron Will
8% of 60 decks +8% synergy
Riot Control
8% of 60 decks +6% synergy
Return to Dust
8% of 60 decks -5% synergy
Rebuff the Wicked
8% of 60 decks -8% synergy
Akroma's Will
8% of 60 decks -15% synergy
Loran's Escape
7% of 60 decks -2% synergy
Brave the Elements
7% of 60 decks -7% synergy
Sorceries
Dusk // Dawn
33% of 60 decks +28% synergy
Fell the Mighty
28% of 60 decks +26% synergy
Cut a Deal
25% of 60 decks +12% synergy
Fumigate
23% of 60 decks +16% synergy
Farewell
23% of 60 decks -2% synergy
Austere Command
22% of 60 decks -8% synergy
Storm Herd
20% of 60 decks +17% synergy
Secret Rendezvous
20% of 60 decks +8% synergy
Slaughter the Strong
18% of 60 decks +17% synergy
Another Round
18% of 17 decks +10% synergy
Lay Down Arms
12% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Open the Armory
12% of 60 decks -2% synergy
Wrath of God
12% of 60 decks -6% synergy
Approach of the Second Sun
10% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Idyllic Tutor
10% of 60 decks +1% synergy
White Sun's Twilight
10% of 60 decks +0% synergy
Expel the Interlopers
9% of 45 decks +6% synergy
Sevinne's Reclamation
8% of 60 decks -6% synergy
Wave of Reckoning
7% of 60 decks +6% synergy
Settle Beyond Reality
7% of 60 decks +6% synergy
Sanctify
7% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Gift of Estates
7% of 60 decks -2% synergy
Mass Calcify
7% of 60 decks -5% synergy
Utility Artifacts
Bumbleflower's Sharepot
75% of 4 decks +74% synergy
The Underworld Cookbook
50% of 60 decks +49% synergy
Carrot Cake
50% of 6 decks +48% synergy
Witch's Oven
45% of 60 decks +44% synergy
Slagwurm Armor
43% of 60 decks +43% synergy
Nuka-Cola Vending Machine
41% of 39 decks +40% synergy
Candy Trail
41% of 44 decks +40% synergy
Swiftfoot Boots
37% of 60 decks -1% synergy
Aetherflux Reservoir
33% of 60 decks +24% synergy
Oketra's Monument
30% of 60 decks -1% synergy
Conjurer's Closet
28% of 60 decks +22% synergy
Well of Lost Dreams
28% of 60 decks +19% synergy
Pearl Medallion
28% of 60 decks -18% synergy
Three Bowls of Porridge
27% of 45 decks +26% synergy
Alhammarret's Archive
27% of 60 decks +22% synergy
Panharmonicon
25% of 60 decks +13% synergy
Wayfarer's Bauble
25% of 60 decks +10% synergy
Cathar's Shield
20% of 60 decks +19% synergy
Trading Post
18% of 60 decks +16% synergy
Cosmos Elixir
18% of 60 decks +12% synergy
Transmutation Font
18% of 17 decks +17% synergy
The Book of Exalted Deeds
17% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Lightning Greaves
17% of 60 decks -14% synergy
Golden Argosy
13% of 60 decks +11% synergy
Idol of Oblivion
13% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Archaeomancer's Map
13% of 60 decks -13% synergy
Accorder's Shield
10% of 60 decks +9% synergy
Endless Atlas
10% of 60 decks -1% synergy
Mithril Coat
8% of 59 decks -1% synergy
Skeleton Key
8% of 60 decks +7% synergy
Trailblazer's Boots
8% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Eriette's Tempting Apple
7% of 44 decks +6% synergy
Angel's Feather
7% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Nettlecyst
7% of 60 decks +3% synergy
Robe of Stars
7% of 60 decks +1% synergy
Sword of Hearth and Home
7% of 60 decks -4% synergy
Sword of the Animist
7% of 60 decks -13% synergy
The One Ring
5% of 59 decks -6% synergy
Enchantments
Fortifying Provisions
45% of 60 decks +45% synergy
Food Coma
43% of 44 decks +43% synergy
Eland Umbra
40% of 60 decks +38% synergy
Far Traveler
37% of 60 decks +33% synergy
Ghostly Prison
28% of 60 decks +10% synergy
Angelic Chorus
27% of 60 decks +24% synergy
Cleric Class
27% of 60 decks +19% synergy
Smothering Tithe
27% of 60 decks -12% synergy
Anointed Procession
25% of 60 decks +11% synergy
Land Tax
25% of 60 decks -6% synergy
Dawn of Hope
23% of 60 decks +14% synergy
Trouble in Pairs
18% of 22 decks -3% synergy
Duelist's Heritage
15% of 60 decks +12% synergy
All That Glitters
15% of 60 decks +3% synergy
Dawn of a New Age
14% of 59 decks +5% synergy
True Conviction
13% of 60 decks +3% synergy
Authority of the Consuls
13% of 60 decks +0% synergy
Tocasia's Welcome
13% of 60 decks -3% synergy
Gauntlets of Light
12% of 60 decks +11% synergy
Griffin Aerie
12% of 60 decks +8% synergy
Brave the Sands
12% of 60 decks +8% synergy
Ajani's Welcome
12% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Flaming Fist
10% of 60 decks +8% synergy
Boon Reflection
10% of 60 decks +8% synergy
Light of Promise
10% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Sigarda's Splendor
10% of 60 decks +3% synergy
Smuggler's Share
10% of 60 decks +0% synergy
Blind Obedience
10% of 60 decks -3% synergy
Flowering of the White Tree
8% of 59 decks -9% synergy
Conclave's Blessing
8% of 60 decks +8% synergy
Test of Endurance
8% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Monologue Tax
8% of 60 decks +3% synergy
Angelic Accord
8% of 60 decks -2% synergy
Darksteel Mutation
8% of 60 decks -10% synergy
Gift of Immortality
7% of 60 decks +1% synergy
Touch the Spirit Realm
7% of 60 decks +1% synergy
Spirit Mantle
7% of 60 decks -2% synergy
War of the Last Alliance
5% of 59 decks +3% synergy
Planeswalkers
The Eternal Wanderer
17% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Ajani, Strength of the Pride
7% of 60 decks +2% synergy
Utility Lands
Rogue's Passage
53% of 60 decks +30% synergy
Access Tunnel
50% of 60 decks +48% synergy
Minas Tirith
41% of 59 decks +6% synergy
War Room
40% of 60 decks -1% synergy
Reliquary Tower
35% of 60 decks +14% synergy
Secluded Steppe
25% of 60 decks +9% synergy
Emeria, the Sky Ruin
25% of 60 decks -15% synergy
Forbidding Watchtower
23% of 60 decks +22% synergy
Karoo
18% of 60 decks +10% synergy
Castle Ardenvale
18% of 60 decks -3% synergy
Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx
15% of 60 decks -19% synergy
Volatile Fault
14% of 28 decks +13% synergy
Temple of the False God
12% of 60 decks -1% synergy
Hidden Courtyard
11% of 35 decks +7% synergy
Drifting Meadow
10% of 60 decks +4% synergy
Scavenger Grounds
10% of 60 decks +2% synergy
Windbrisk Heights
8% of 60 decks -10% synergy
Eiganjo, Seat of the Empire
8% of 60 decks -18% synergy
Sandstone Bridge
7% of 60 decks +6% synergy
Guildless Commons
7% of 60 decks +3% synergy
Desert of the True
7% of 60 decks +3% synergy
Idyllic Grange
7% of 60 decks -2% synergy
Buried Ruin
7% of 60 decks -5% synergy
Hall of Heliod's Generosity
7% of 60 decks -6% synergy
Urza's Saga
7% of 60 decks -6% synergy
Mana Artifacts
Sol Ring
90% of 60 decks +4% synergy
Arcane Signet
68% of 60 decks +8% synergy
Marble Diamond
35% of 60 decks +12% synergy
Mind Stone
35% of 60 decks -1% synergy
Golden Egg
33% of 60 decks +32% synergy
Thought Vessel
30% of 60 decks +14% synergy
Commander's Sphere
17% of 60 decks +5% synergy
Pristine Talisman
15% of 60 decks +10% synergy
Throne of Eldraine
14% of 44 decks -9% synergy
Fellwar Stone
12% of 60 decks +1% synergy
Caged Sun
8% of 60 decks -4% synergy
Hedron Archive
7% of 60 decks +2% synergy
Thran Dynamo
7% of 60 decks +0% synergy
Lands
Myriad Landscape
33% of 60 decks -1% synergy
Evolving Wilds
17% of 60 decks +12% synergy
Terramorphic Expanse
13% of 60 decks +10% synergy
Escape Tunnel
12% of 25 decks +11% synergy
Brokers Hideout
8% of 60 decks +7% synergy
Command Tower
8% of 60 decks +2% synergy
Demolition Field
8% of 60 decks +1% synergy
Cabaretti Courtyard
7% of 60 decks +6% synergy
Shire Terrace
5% of 59 decks +5% synergy