Which Lord of the Rings commanders have been most popular in practice? Kyle reviews his predictions one year on!
The Over/Under - A Review of The Lord of the Rings Commanders
![Bilbo-Birthday-Scene-Full-art-Artist-Livia-Prima](https://media.edhrec.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Bilbo-Birthday-Scene-Full-art-Artist-Livia-Prima-150x150.png)
#Aragorn and Arwen Wed, #Aragorn Company Leader, #aragorn king of gondor, #Aragorn the Uniter, #Arwen Mortal Queen, #Arwen Undómiel, #Arwen Weaver of Hope, #Beregond of the Guard, #Bilbo Birthday Celebrant, #Bilbo Retired Burglar, #Bill Ferny Bree Swindler, #Bill the Pony, #Boromir Gondor's Hope, #Boromir Warden of the Tower, #Butterbur Bree Innkeeper, #Celeborn the Wise, #Círdan the Shipwright, #Denethor Ruling Steward, #Denethor Stone Seer, #Elanor Gardner, #Elrond Lord of Rivendell, #Elrond Master of Healing, #Elrond of the White Council, #Éomer King of Rohan, #Éomer Marshal of Rohan, #Éomer of the Riddermark, #Éowyn Fearless Knight, #Éowyn Lady of Rohan, #Éowyn Shieldmaiden, #Erestor of the Council, #Erkenbrand Lord of Westfold, #Fangorn Tree Shepherd, #Faramir Field Commander, #Faramir Prince of Ithilien, #Faramir Steward of Gondor, #Farmer Cotton, #Frodo Adventurous Hobbit, #Frodo Baggins, #Frodo Determined Hero, #Frodo Sauron's Bane, #Galadriel Elven-Queen, #Galadriel Gift-Giver, #Galadriel of Lothlórien, #Gandalf the Grey, #Gandalf the White, #Gandalf Westward Voyager, #Gandalf White Rider, #Gilraen Dúnedain Protector, #Gimli Counter of Kills, #Gimli Mournful Avenger, #Gimli of the Glittering Caves, #Glóin Dwarf Emissary, #Glorfindel Dauntless Rescuer, #Goldberry River-Daughter, #Gollum Obsessed Stalker, #Gollum Patient Plotter, #Gollum Scheming Guide, #Gorbag of Minas Morgul, #Gothmog Morgul Lieutenant, #Gríma Saruman's Footman, #Gríma Wormtongue, #Grishnákh Brash Instigator, #Gwaihir Greatest of the Eagles, #Gwaihir the Windlord, #Haldir Lórien Lieutenant, #Ioreth of the Healing House, #King of the Oathbreakers, #Landroval Horizon Witness, #Legolas Counter of Kills, #Legolas Greenleaf, #Legolas Master Archer, #Liliana the necromancer, #Lobelia Defender of Bag End, #Lobelia Sackville-Baggins, #Lord of the Nazgûl, #lord of the rings tales from middle-earth, #Lotho Corrupt Shirriff, #Mauhúr Uruk-hai Captain, #Meneldor Swift Savior, #Meriadoc Brandybuck, #Merry Warden of Isengard, #Monstrosity of the Lake, #Old Man Willow, #Peregrin Took, #Pippin Guard of the Citadel, #Pippin Warden of Isengard, #Prince Imrahil the Fair, #Quickbeam Upstart Ent, #Radagast the Brown, #Radagast Wizard of Wilds, #Rosie Cotton of South Lane, #Sam Loyal Attendant, #Samwise Gamgee, #Samwise the Stouthearted, #Saradoc Master of Buckland, #Saruman of Many Colors, #Saruman the White, #Saruman the White Hand, #Sauron Lord of the Rings, #Sauron the Dark Lord, #Sauron the Lidless Eye, #Shadowfax Lord of Horses, #Shagrat Loot Bearer, #Sharkey Tyrant of the Shire, #Shelob Child of Ungoliant, #Shelob Dread Weaver, #Sméagol Helpful Guide, #Strider Ranger of the North, #The Balrog Durin's Bane, #The Balrog Flame of Udûn, #The Balrog of Moria, #The Gaffer, #The Mouth of Sauron, #the over/under, #The Watcher in the Water, #Théoden King of Rohan, #Tom Bombadil, #Treebeard Gracious Host, #Uglúk of the White Hand, #Witch-king Bringer of Ruin, #Witch-king of Angmar Read More »
The Over/Under - Predicting the Popularity of Assassin's Creed Commanders
![set review header for assassin's creed over under](https://media.edhrec.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/acr-over.under_-150x150.png)
Kyle predicts which commanders will head up over or under 1,200 decks for Assassin's Creed!
#Achilles Davenport, #Adéwalé Breaker of Chains, #Alexios Deimos of Kosmos, #Altaïr Ibn-La'Ahad, #Arbaaz Mir, #Arno Dorian, #assassin's creed, #Aveline de Grandpré, #Aya of Alexandria, #Basim Ibn Ishaq, #Bayek of Siwa, #Cleopatra Exiled Pharaoh, #Desmond Miles, #Edward Kenway, #Eivor Battle-Ready, #Eivor Wolf-Kissed, #Evie Frye, #Ezio Auditore da Firenze, #Ezio Blade of Vengeance, #Ezio Brash Novice, #Havi the All-Father, #Haytham Kenway, #Jacob Frye, #Kassandra Eagle Bearer, #Layla Hassan, #Leonardo da Vinci, #Mary Read and Anne Bonny, #Ratonhnhaké꞉ton, #Roshan Hidden Magister, #Senu Keen-Eyed Protector, #Shao Jun, #Shaun & Rebecca Agents, #Shay Cormac, #Sigurd Jarl of Ravensthorpe, #Sokrates Athenian Teacher, #Surtr Fiery Jötun, #the 600, #the over/under Read More »
The Over/Under - Predicting the Popularity of Modern Horizons 3 Commanders
![](https://media.edhrec.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Set-Review-White-41-150x150.png)
Which commander will come out on top from Modern Horizons 3?
#Ajani Nacatl Pariah, #Arna Kennerüd Skycaptain, #Ashling Flame Dancer, #Azlask the Swelling Scourge, #Cayth Famed Mechanist, #Coram the Undertaker, #Disa the Restless, #Eladamri Korvecdal, #Emrakul the World Anew, #Genku Future Shaper, #Grist Voracious Larva, #Herigast Erupting Nullkite, #Imskir Iron-Eater, #Jyoti Moag Ancient, #Kozilek the Broken Reality, #Kudo King Among Bears, #modern horizons 3, #Nadu Winged Wisdom, #Omo Queen of Vesuva, #Pearl-Ear Imperial Advisor, #Phelia Exuberant Shepherd, #Phlage Titan of Fire's Fury, #Ral Monsoon Mage, #Rosheen Roaring Prophet, #Satya Aetherflux Genius, #Shilgengar Sire of Famine, #Six, #Skoa Embermage, #Sorin of House Markov, #Tamiyo Inquisitive Student, #the 600, #The Necrobloom, #the over/under, #Ulamog the Defiler Read More »
The Over/Under - A Review of March of the Machine: The Aftermath Commanders
![](https://media.edhrec.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/MTG-Aftermath-Nahiri.jpg-copy-150x150.png)
Who came out on top from March of the Machine: The Aftermath? Kyle reviews his Commander predictions.
#Arni Metalbrow, #Calix Guided by Fate, #Danitha New Benalia's Light, #Jirina Dauntless General, #Jolrael Voice of Zhalfir, #Karn Legacy Reforged, #Kiora Sovereign of the Deep, #Nahiri Forged in Fury, #Narset Enlightened Exile, #Nashi Moon's Legacy, #Nissa Resurgent Animist, #Niv-Mizzet Supreme, #Ob Nixilis Captive Kingpin, #Pia Nalaar consul of revival, #Plargg and Nassari, #Rocco Street Chef, #Samut Vizier of Naktamun, #Sarkhan Soul Aflame, #Sigarda Font of Blessings, #the 600, #the over/under, #Tyvar the Bellicose Read More »
The Over/Under - A Review of March of the Machine Commanders
![](https://media.edhrec.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/MOM-Header-150x150.png)
Kyle gives us the results of his Over Under for March of the Machine.
#Ayara Widow of the Realm, #Baral and Kari Zev, #Borborygmos and Fblthp, #Bright-Palm Soul Awakener, #Brimaz Blight of Oreskos, #Djeru and Hazoret, #Drana and Linvala, #Elenda and Azor, #elesh norn, #Errant and Giada, #Etali Primal Conqueror, #Ghalta and Mavren, #Gimbal Gremlin Prodigy, #Glissa Herald of Predation, #Goro-Goro and Satoru, #Heliod the Radiant Dawn, #Heliod the Warped Eclipse, #Hidetsugu and Kairi, #Inga and Esika, #jin-gitaxias, #Kasla the Broken Halo, #Katilda and Lier, #Kogla and Yidaro, #Kroxa and Kunoros, #march of the machine, #Moira and Teshar, #Omnath Locus of All, #Orthion Hero of Lavabrink, #Polukranos Reborn, #Quintorius Loremaster, #Rankle and Torbran, #Rashmi and Ragavan, #Rona Herald of Invasion, #Saint Traft and Rem Karolus, #sheoldred, #Sidar Jabari of Zhalfir, #Slimefoot and Squee, #Surrak and Goreclaw, #Thalia and The Gitrog Monster, #the 600, #the over/under, #Urabrask, #vorinclex, #Yargle and Multani, #Zimone and Dina, #Zurgo and Ojutai Read More »
The Over/Under - Predicting the Popularity of Outlaws of Thunder Junction Commanders
![](https://media.edhrec.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/Rakdos-150x150.png)
Who will be the best commander from Outlaws of Thunder Junction?
#Akul the Unrepentant, #Annie Flash the Veteran, #Baron Bertram Graywater, #Bonny Pall Clearcutter, #Breeches the Blastmaker, #Bristly Bill Spine Sower, #Bruse Tarl Roving Rancher, #Calamity Galloping Inferno, #Doc Aurlock Grizzled Genius, #Eriette the Beguiler, #Eris Roar of the Storm, #Ertha Jo Frontier Mentor, #Fblthp Lost on the Range, #Felix Five-Boots, #Fortune Loyal Steed, #Geralf the Fleshwright, #Ghired Mirror of the Wilds, #Gisa the Hellraiser, #Gonti Canny Acquisitor, #Honest Rutstein, #Jem Lightfoote Sky Explorer, #Jolene Plundering Pugilist, #Kaervek the Punisher, #Kambal Profiteering Mayor, #Kellan the Kid, #Kirri Talented Sprout, #Kraum Violent Cacophony, #Laughing Jasper Flint, #Lazav Familiar Stranger, #Lilah Undefeated Slickshot, #Loot the Key to Everything, #Magda the Hoardmaster, #Malcolm the Eyes, #Marchesa Dealer of Death, #Miriam Herd Whisperer, #Obeka Splitter of Seconds, #Olivia Opulent Outlaw, #outlaws of thunder junction, #rakdos the muscle, #Riku of Many Paths, #Roxanne Starfall Savant, #Satoru the Infiltrator, #Selvala Eager Trailblazer, #Stella Lee Wild Card, #Taii Wakeen Perfect Shot, #the 600, #The Gitrog Ravenous Ride, #the over/under, #Tinybones the Pickpocket, #Vadmir New Blood, #Vial Smasher Gleeful Grenadier, #Vihaan Goldwaker, #Vraska the Silencer, #Wylie Duke Atiin Hero, #yuma proud protector Read More »
Commander Cube Revisited: A Few Do's and Don'ts
![](https://media.edhrec.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Sol-Ring-Image-1-150x150.png)
Thinking about Commander Cube? Kyle gives some quick tips to make your next Cube outing shine.
#commander cube, #primer, #rules, #tech, #theory Read More »
The Over/Under - Predicting the Popularity of Fallout Commanders
![](https://media.edhrec.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Fallout_OverUnder-150x150.png)
Who will be the best commander from Fallout?
#Agent Frank Horrigan, #Aradesh the Founder, #Arcade Gannon, #Butch DeLoria Tunnel Snake, #Caesar Legion's Emperor, #Cait Cage Brawler, #Cass Hand of Vengeance, #Codsworth Handy Helper, #Colonel Autumn, #Commander Sofia Daguerre, #Craig Boone Novac Guard, #Curie Emergent Intelligence, #Desdemona Freedom's Edge, #Dogmeat Ever Loyal, #Dr. Madison Li, #Duchess Wayward Tavernkeep, #ED-E Lonesome Eyebot, #Elder Arthur Maxson, #Elder Owyn Lyons, #fallout, #Hancock Ghoulish Mayor, #Harold and Bob First Numens, #Ian the Reckless, #James Wandering Dad, #Jason Bright Glowing Prophet, #Kellogg Dangerous Mind, #Legate Lanius Caesar's Ace, #Liberty Prime Recharged, #Lily Bowen Raging Grandma, #MacCready Lamplight Mayor, #Marcus Mutant Mayor, #Moira Brown Guide Author, #Mr. House President and CEO, #Nick Valentine Private Eye, #Overseer of Vault 76, #Paladin Danse Steel Maverick, #Paladin Elizabeth Taggerdy, #Piper Wright Publick Reporter, #Preston Garvey Minuteman, #Raul Trouble Shooter, #Red Death Shipwrecker, #Rex Cyber-Hound, #Rose Cutthroat Raider, #Sentinel Sarah Lyons, #Sierra Nuka's Biggest Fan, #Strong the Brutish Thespian, #the 600, #The Motherlode Excavator, #the over/under, #The Wise Mothman, #Three Dog Galaxy News DJ, #Veronica Dissident Scribe, #Yes Man Personal Securitron Read More »
The Over/Under - A Review of Phyrexia: All Will Be One Commanders
![](https://media.edhrec.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/image16.png-150x150.webp)
Who turned out to be the best commander from Phyrexia?
#Atraxa Grand Unifier, #Chiss-Goria Forge Tyrant, #Drivnod Carnage Dominus, #Elesh Norn Mother of Machines, #Ezuri Stalker of Spheres, #Geth Thane of Contracts, #Glissa Sunslayer, #Graaz Unstoppable Juggernaut, #Ixhel Scion of Atraxa, #Jor Kadeen First Goldwarden, #Karumonix the Rat King, #Kemba Kha Enduring, #Kethek Crucible Goliath, #Kinzu of the Bleak Coven, #Melira the Living Cure, #Migloz Maze Crusher, #Mondrak Glory Dominus, #Neyali Suns' Vanguard, #Otharri Suns' Glory, #Ovika Enigma Goliath, #phyrexia, #phyrexia all will be one, #Rhuk Hexgold Nabber, #Ria Ivor Bane of Bladehold, #Skrelv Defector Mite, #Slobad Iron Goblin, #Solphim Mayhem Dominus, #Tekuthal Inquiry Dominus, #the 600, #the over/under, #Thrun Breaker of Silence, #Unctus Grand Metatect, #Urtet Remnant of Memnarch, #Venser Corpse Puppet, #Vishgraz the Doomhive, #Vraan Executioner Thane, #Zopandrel Hunger Dominus Read More »
The Over/Under - Predicting The Popularity Of Murders At Karlov Manor And Clue Commanders
![OverUnder_MKM header](https://media.edhrec.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/OverUnder_MKM-150x150.png)
Who will be the best Murders of Karlov Manor commander?
#Agrus Kos Spirit of Justice, #Alquist Proft Master Sleuth, #Amzu Swarm's Hunger, #Anzrag the Quake-Mole, #Apothecary White, #Aurelia the Law Above, #Commander Mustard, #Delney Streetwise Lookout, #Duskana the Rage Mother, #Emissary Green, #Etrata Deadly Fugitive, #Ezrim Agency Chief, #Feather Radiant Arbiter, #Headliner Scarlett, #Izoni Center of the Web, #Judith Carnage Connoisseur, #Kaust Eyes of the Glade, #Kellan Inquisitive Prodigy, #Krenko Baron of Tin Street, #Kylox Visionary Inventor, #Lavinia Foil to Conspiracy, #Lazav Wearer of Faces, #Lonis Genetics Expert, #Marvo Deep Operative, #Massacre Girl Known Killer, #Mastermind Plum, #Melek Reforged Researcher, #Mirko Obsessive Theorist, #Morska Undersea Sleuth, #murders at karlov manor, #Nelly Borca Impulsive Accuser, #Niv-Mizzet Guildpact, #Rakdos Patron of Chaos, #Senator Peacock, #Sophia Dogged Detective, #Tesak Judith's Hellhound, #Teysa Opulent Oligarch, #the 600, #the over/under, #The Pride of Hull Clade, #Tolsimir Midnight's Light, #Tomik Wielder of Law, #Trostani Three Whispers, #Vannifar Evolved Enigma, #Voja Jaws of the Conclave, #Yarus Roar of the Gods Read More »