Withar, Cocoon Keeper (Commander) - Budget Optimized

Original Name:

Mister NegativeMister Negative

Withar, Cocoon Keeper
Rank #471
25decks
As CommanderAs CardAverage DeckDecks
Bracket
All
1
2345
Budget
Any$$$$
Andy Zupke
Dec 11, 2025
Andy Zupke
The EDHREC Writers' Favorite New Commanders of 2025
The writing staff at EDHREC gives you the rundown on their favorite new commanders that came out in 2025. Is your favorite on the list?
Deck Filters
Cardsphere
Archidekt
Commander Spellbook
Moxfield
Scryfall
MTGStocks
New Cards
Top Cards
High Lift Cards
Creatures
Instants
Sorceries
Utility Artifacts
Enchantments
Planeswalkers
Utility Lands
Mana Artifacts
Lands
Back to Top
Germinate Recruits
25%inclusion1 decks4 decks
12xlift
Rescue Girl, First Responder
25%inclusion1 decks4 decks
18xlift
Top Cards
Sanguine Bond
80%inclusion20 decks25 decks
2.2xlift
Cloudshift
68%inclusion17 decks25 decks
10xlift
Swords to Plowshares
68%inclusion17 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Children of Korlis
60%inclusion15 decks25 decks
8.3xlift
Charming Prince
56%inclusion14 decks25 decks
12xlift
Ephemerate
56%inclusion14 decks25 decks
10xlift
Daydream
54%inclusion7 decks13 decks
25xlift
Wall of Blood
52%inclusion13 decks25 decks
19xlift
Platinum Angel
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
18xlift
Phyrexian Unlife
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
13xlift
High Lift Cards
The Spot's Portal
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
26xlift
Risky Research
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
20xlift
Acrobatic Maneuver
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
19xlift
False Cure
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
18xlift
Blood Celebrant
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
18xlift
Unspeakable Symbol
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
18xlift
Eldrazi Displacer
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
17xlift
Doom Whisperer
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
17xlift
Evra, Halcyon Witness
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
17xlift
Justiciar's Portal
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
16xlift
Creatures
Vito, Thorn of the Dusk Rose
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Solemn Simulacrum
44%inclusion11 decks25 decks
3.4xlift
K'rrik, Son of Yawgmoth
44%inclusion11 decks25 decks
10xlift
Gray Merchant of Asphodel
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
2.7xlift
Restoration Angel
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
7.8xlift
Astarion, the Decadent
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
3.4xlift
Dark Confidant
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
6.3xlift
Vizkopa Guildmage
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
2.9xlift
Tree of Perdition
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
14xlift
Felidar Guardian
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
6.2xlift
Rhox Faithmender
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
3.7xlift
Flickerwisp
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
10xlift
Enduring Tenacity
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Soul Warden
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Herald of Eternal Dawn
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
10xlift
Kambal, Consul of Allocation
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Black Widow, Double Agent
22%inclusion2 decks9 decks
17xlift
Ronin, Shadow Stalker
22%inclusion2 decks9 decks
42xlift
Darkstar Augur
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
5.0xlift
Gwenom, Remorseless
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
7.6xlift
Bloodthirsty Conqueror
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.5xlift
Suture Priest
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Vilis, Broker of Blood
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
7.6xlift
Psychosis Crawler
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
9.4xlift
Phelia, Exuberant Shepherd
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
6.7xlift
Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Distinguished Conjurer
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
4.3xlift
Bloodletter of Aclazotz
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
2.7xlift
Archivist of Oghma
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
4.8xlift
Ravenous Chupacabra
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
8.6xlift
Defiant Bloodlord
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
2.1xlift
Witch Enchanter
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
3.8xlift
Knight of the White Orchid
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
3.2xlift
Aunt May
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
8.6xlift
Plague Drone
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
13xlift
Magus of the Mirror
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
10xlift
Dusk Legion Zealot
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.6xlift
Inspiring Overseer
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
3.2xlift
Loran of the Third Path
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.7xlift
Sun Titan
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
0.3xlift
Marauding Blight-Priest
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
0.4xlift
Boggart Trawler
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
3.3xlift
Wall of Omens
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
6.0xlift
Ornithopter of Paradise
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
7.4xlift
Grand Abolisher
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.2xlift
Blood Artist
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
0.3xlift
Gilraen, Dúnedain Protector
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
10xlift
Corpse Knight
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Soul's Attendant
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Instants
Flicker of Fate
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
12xlift
Anguished Unmaking
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Path to Exile
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Parting Gust
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
8.7xlift
Dark Ritual
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Generous Gift
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.8xlift
Scrollshift
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
16xlift
Despark
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Personify
22%inclusion4 decks18 decks
11xlift
Getaway Glamer
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
12xlift
Reprieve
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
2.6xlift
Eerie Interlude
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
6.1xlift
Stunning Reversal
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
13xlift
Angel's Grace
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
4.8xlift
Infernal Grasp
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Slip On the Ring
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
8.0xlift
Beacon of Immortality
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
3.7xlift
Not Dead After All
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
3.0xlift
Necrologia
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
11xlift
Ad Nauseam
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
3.7xlift
Stroke of Midnight
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Ghostway
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
7.4xlift
Heliod's Intervention
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Fracture
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Mortify
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
0.4xlift
Comeuppance
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
8.0xlift
Fell the Profane
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Orzhov Charm
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.6xlift
Snuff Out
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
6.4xlift
Semester's End
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
6.4xlift
Lae'zel's Acrobatics
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
9.2xlift
Flare of Fortitude
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.0xlift
Vanishing Verse
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Bitter Triumph
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Undying Malice
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.6xlift
Mana Tithe
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.8xlift
Disenchant
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Inkshield
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
Vampiric Tutor
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Liberate
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
21xlift
Fight On!
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.3xlift
Spectacular Tactics
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
11xlift
Sudden Strike
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
21xlift
Ajani's Response
7.7%inclusion1 decks13 decks
38xlift
Wander Off
7.7%inclusion1 decks13 decks
9.5xlift
Grounded for Life
6.7%inclusion1 decks15 decks
13xlift
Sorceries
Toxic Deluge
44%inclusion11 decks25 decks
3.8xlift
Exsanguinate
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Damn
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Diabolic Tutor
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Night's Whisper
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.9xlift
Farewell
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
2.1xlift
Feed the Swarm
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
2.1xlift
Fumigate
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Peer into the Abyss
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
8.9xlift
Debt to the Deathless
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Revival // Revenge
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
2.1xlift
Reanimate
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Sign in Blood
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Repay in Kind
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
7.5xlift
Merciless Eviction
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
2.9xlift
Cleansing Nova
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
4.4xlift
Kaya's Wrath
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
1.5xlift
Damnable Pact
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
12xlift
Profane Transfusion
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
10xlift
Wrath of God
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Read the Bones
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Vindicate
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Another Round
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
10xlift
Vanquish the Horde
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Insatiable Avarice
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Day of Judgment
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.9xlift
Zero Point Ballad
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
14xlift
Venom's Hunger
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
32xlift
Villainous Wrath
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
14xlift
Murdock's Crusade
11%inclusion1 decks9 decks
42xlift
Morningtide's Light
8.7%inclusion2 decks23 decks
8.5xlift
Austere Command
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.5xlift
Ondu Inversion
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
7.1xlift
Victimize
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.5xlift
Profane Tutor
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.9xlift
Settle Beyond Reality
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
32xlift
Scheming Symmetry
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.6xlift
Dark Petition
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.3xlift
Final Parting
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.2xlift
Diresight
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Reverse the Sands
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.9xlift
Beseech the Mirror
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
11xlift
Plague of Vermin
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
11xlift
Against All Odds
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
11xlift
Behold the Sinister Six!
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
21xlift
Utility Artifacts
Conjurer's Closet
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
10xlift
Tainted Sigil
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
8.0xlift
Bolas's Citadel
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.9xlift
Panharmonicon
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
14xlift
Swiftfoot Boots
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Wayfarer's Bauble
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.5xlift
The Wind Crystal
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
2.5xlift
Jet Medallion
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
2.5xlift
Pearl Medallion
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.2xlift
Phyrexian Processor
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
12xlift
Aetherflux Reservoir
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Pact Weapon
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
8.0xlift
Alhammarret's Archive
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.8xlift
The Darkness Crystal
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.1xlift
The Endstone
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
24xlift
Vibranium Energy Daggers
11%inclusion1 decks9 decks
21xlift
The Book of Exalted Deeds
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
6.4xlift
Well of Lost Dreams
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Soul Conduit
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
7.1xlift
Mindcrank
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
9.2xlift
Lightning Greaves
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
Archaeomancer's Map
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.9xlift
Venser's Journal
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.9xlift
Requiem Monolith
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
21xlift
Enchantments
Teleportation Circle
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
15xlift
Phyrexian Arena
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Tainted Remedy
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
9.3xlift
Exquisite Blood
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Wound Reflection
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
5.9xlift
Dark Tutelage
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
7.1xlift
Axis of Mortality
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
8.7xlift
Black Market Connections
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
2.8xlift
Airbender Ascension
19%inclusion4 decks21 decks
10xlift
Glasswing Grace
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
Authority of the Consuls
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Near-Death Experience
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
10xlift
Underworld Connections
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
4.0xlift
Blind Obedience
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
Boon Reflection
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
4.2xlift
Web Up
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
24xlift
Parker Luck
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
16xlift
Quantum Entanglement
11%inclusion1 decks9 decks
41xlift
Case of the Uneaten Feast
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.3xlift
Greed
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Black Market
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Midnight Snack
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.6xlift
Touch the Spirit Realm
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.7xlift
Phyrexian Reclamation
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.1xlift
Smile at Death
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
3.6xlift
Necrodominance
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.6xlift
Kaya's Ghostform
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Animate Dead
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Ghostly Prison
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
Solemnity
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
3.8xlift
The Death of Gwen Stacy
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
13xlift
Planeswalkers
Kaya, Ghost Assassin
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
11xlift
Gideon of the Trials
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
21xlift
Utility Lands
Reliquary Tower
60%inclusion15 decks25 decks
3.6xlift
Bojuka Bog
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Rogue's Passage
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Temple of the False God
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Vault of the Archangel
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
Orzhova, the Church of Deals
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
6.9xlift
Shambling Vent
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Mutavault
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
7.1xlift
Piranha Marsh
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
11xlift
Witch's Cottage
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.4xlift
Radiant Fountain
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Cabal Coffers
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
6.4xlift
Restless Fortress
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
7.1xlift
Multiversal Passage
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
13xlift
Realm of Koh
5.3%inclusion1 decks19 decks
1.5xlift
Abandoned Air Temple
5.0%inclusion1 decks20 decks
3.3xlift
Mana Artifacts
Sol Ring
100%inclusion25 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Arcane Signet
88%inclusion22 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Thought Vessel
60%inclusion15 decks25 decks
5.3xlift
Orzhov Signet
60%inclusion15 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Talisman of Hierarchy
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Mind Stone
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Commander's Sphere
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Charcoal Diamond
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
3.8xlift
Marble Diamond
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
3.4xlift
Fellwar Stone
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Phial of Galadriel
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
13xlift
Orzhov Locket
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
4.1xlift
Pristine Talisman
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Decanter of Endless Water
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
5.1xlift
Gilded Lotus
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
7.4xlift
Thran Dynamo
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
8.0xlift
Worn Powerstone
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
8.0xlift
Orzhov Cluestone
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.6xlift
Everflowing Chalice
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
5.3xlift
Hedron Archive
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
5.3xlift
Potioner's Trove
7.7%inclusion1 decks13 decks
9.5xlift
Firdoch Core
5.6%inclusion1 decks18 decks
12xlift
Lands
Swamp
96%inclusion24 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Plains
96%inclusion24 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Command Tower
68%inclusion17 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Caves of Koilos
68%inclusion17 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Isolated Chapel
64%inclusion16 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Orzhov Basilica
56%inclusion14 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Godless Shrine
52%inclusion13 decks25 decks
2.1xlift
Tainted Field
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Scoured Barrens
44%inclusion11 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Temple of Silence
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Fetid Heath
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Evolving Wilds
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Shineshadow Snarl
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Terramorphic Expanse
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.5xlift
Exotic Orchard
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Myriad Landscape
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Path of Ancestry
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Fisk Tower
22%inclusion2 decks9 decks
12xlift
Concealed Courtyard
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Orzhov Guildgate
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Forsaken Sanctuary
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
2.0xlift
Shattered Sanctum
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Witch Enchanter
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
3.8xlift
Brightclimb Pathway
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
1.8xlift
Glasswing Grace
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
Desolate Mire
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Snowfield Sinkhole
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Silent Clearing
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
4.0xlift
Foot Headquarters
13%inclusion2 decks15 decks
3.4xlift
Bleachbone Verge
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Boggart Trawler
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
3.3xlift
Marsh Flats
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
Forlorn Flats
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Vault of Champions
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Vibrant Cityscape
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
6.0xlift
Misty Palms Oasis
10%inclusion2 decks20 decks
2.5xlift
Fell the Profane
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Ondu Inversion
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
7.1xlift
Sunlit Marsh
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Thriving Moor
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Neglected Manor
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Goldmire Bridge
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Insomnia, Crown City
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.5xlift
Forum of Amity
7.7%inclusion1 decks13 decks
0.7xlift
Umbral Expanse
7.7%inclusion1 decks13 decks
1.6xlift
About UsContactPrivacy PolicyTerms of Service
Space Cow MediaArchidektCardsphereCommander SpellbookFABRECSpellvoid
Space Cow MediaArchidektCommander's Herald
Commander SpellbookFABRECSpellvoid
EDHREC is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Fan Content Policy. Not approved/endorsed by Wizards. Portions of the materials used are property of Wizards of the Coast. ©Wizards of the Coast LLC.
next@15 test